Tony's N.Y. Pizza

"Went in tonight as they advertised pizza by the slice . We go in , sit and read the menu and go up to counter to order pizza by the slice and they told us no cheese or no pepperoni by the slice. My grandson will not eat what we all eat so that is why we choose this place as their menu states pizza by the slice. What the heck??? Saturday night and no cheese by the slice pizza or pepperoni? Rude as no one acknowledged us when we came in. We decided to leave and go next door to subway and had great customer service and great subs. (they make pizza cheese for kids as well)."

"Easily in my top 3 pizza spots on the island, and always quick with the takeout orders. I like mine well done, and if you really want to treat yourself ask for the Grandma's style not sure if they will make it for any Joe Smoe but if you like a thicker crust and extra sauce this is for you."

"How is this possible? The exact same eggplant calzone order one week apart? Such a letdown when all you want is consistency"

"Fabulous spot to grab a meal. We ate in the restaurant but they do a big business in take out. The place was packed on a Thursday night! The eggplant pizza was huge and loaded with eggplant and cheese, my husband had the Caesar salad with grilled chicken that was also a very generous portion. Prices were very reasonable. I will definitely be back."

"Started off with the garlic knots which had the perfect texture to them. Then the BBQ & milk wings were some of the best wings I have ever tried! The pizza tasted so delicious and it wasn't as greasy as most pizza is!"