Tonys N.Y. Pizza 3398 Forum Boulevard, Fort Myers, FL 33905

"An unexpected gem. The by the slice pizza and the salads were amazing. The real star was the best garlic knots I’ve ever had. Their zeppola for desert came in a bunch of 25 and were made fresh. Tiramisu! So good! The service was fast and friendly. Can’t speak well enough about this restaurant."

"Love the atmosphere and the the NYC mural and pictures on the walls. The staff was very friendly, the server very quick and efficient. Truly felt a little like NYC without the congestion outside. They have both inside and outside dining. We ordered a single piece of pizza which was huge and very tasty. Also ordered the garlic knots which did not taste like garlic but were very very tasty without an overpowering garlic taste. The consistency was perfect, taste was just a little bland but adding a little salt and red pepper flakes which were on the table made them more tasty Will definitely return!"

"1st I’ll start off by saying the customer service was great. I didn’t catch her name but the cashier was attentive and knew what my order was before I came in as she even called me to verify my order was correct. I was hoping with a nice start the food would be delicious like the reviews state but either their tastebuds are off or we just didn’t get the best this place could offer. The garlic knots weren’t really flavorful, buttery, or soft like people raved about. Ours was just dry, toasted bread. The pizza was really soggy and the cheese fell right off. The pizza sauce could have used more flavor but the crust at the end was okay. Felt like I could have a more flavorful, non soggy pizza elsewhere for cheaper than here but that’s just my personal experience."

"This is burnt pizza! I called and spoke to Sandra who told me to post a review because she had no other way to see the picture. They could care less there was a unsatisfied, repeat customer which is very disappointing. Sandra told me she is the one that cut my pizza, and didn’t see a problem. I asked if she looked at the bottom?!"