Caddy's Treasure Island

"Beautiful location and friendly service but the food is way overpriced, bland, and not good. The $17 chicken tender basket came with 4 soggy, flavorless chicken tenders and some fries, the tacos came with only 2 and both them and the chicken sandwich were bland. Food was very disappointing and not worth the money. However, the drinks were delicious (especially the Miami Vice)."

"This is our place to go to after an afternoon at Treasure Island beach. We basically go once or twice a year because this beach is far from our home, but that's enough. This place is expensive and even the parking is crazy expensive. I don't think its worth it, but my wife likes the fact that its on the beach. We do after sun down, so it does not make sense to me. Anyways, I always get the chicken tenders because I do not eat seafood and the other items are not something that catches my attentions, mainly because of the price and amount of food you get. The drinks are expensive, but at least we have a collection of plastic color changing cups a home."

"Caddy's Treasure Island is an all around great experience! We made reservations for Thanksgiving Day and had planned to get the traditional Thanksgiving meal but once seeing the menu decided to go with something else. I'm so glad we did! We had the calamari to start, which was cooked perfectly! For our meal, we had the mahi tacos and the shrimp basket. We got the Key Lime pie for dessert and again were not disappointed. It was light but flavorful and creamy! All of the food was very good and tasted fresh! Our server, Carolina M. was wonderful! She was very attentive but not overly so. She was also very personable. She was kind and took her time with us despite being busy during a Holiday. The atmosphere was fun yet beautiful! There was a large amount of seating and you just can't beat the view!! We can't wait to return to try more things on the menu."

"Beautiful day to spend the afternoon here. Arrived here around 11:30am and it was slowly getting busy. My girlfriends and I rented a Cabana and was worth it! The restaurant provided bottled waters which is a necessity on a hot day. Connor was very attentive server and made our experience pleasant. The food was delicious especially when we were adult drinking. Oh the drinks… they are dangerously delicious and will sneak up on you with a good buzz. Overall a good crowd of people enjoying the beach. Parking is located next to the restaurant. Be mindful of the parking: We had someone get our car out of our parking spot because it got stuck in the sand. Don’t forget to wear sunscreen!"

"Love the DJ & Beach atmosphere. Our server Mike was awesome. Food left a bit to be desired. Pretzel was ok but not for $16 served with cold congealed beer cheese. Mexican street corn was kind of soggy & definitely needed salt & pepper. Grouper Ruben was not the best, Grouper was a bit tough. The fried Grouper sandwich was definitely the best menu item we tried."