Oma's Pizza and Italian Restaurant

"Uses to be our favorite place. This last visit was the end of that service was awful. As we were trying to leave I was getting our toddler out of the booth and a server slammed into with no apology. We had to ask 3 times for a to go box. The drinks were nothing but carbonation. The food was even lacking. For the prices I expected way better than this. We used to make a monthly trip over just for omas. We won't be returning."

"It was so good, we ate here 2 nights! Best pizza in town. Paula was great. We will definitely be back next year!"

"We would have never come here without the recommendation from Janice. The food was great but she was the experience! Ask for her, she will steer you right with the food. They are so lucky to have her! She made the experience worthwhile! Will recommend the food because of her and we will be back to see her. Love from Ohio! Xoxo"

"Oma’s was a bright spot on an otherwise dreary evening. Popped into Oma’s on a rainy night. Wow - glad we tried it. Atmosphere is so cozy. And you can’t ask for nicer, helpful staff. Kinda felt like we were family. Of course, the most important thing is the food - and Oma’s was so good. I had the fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp - fresh and delicious. Everyone enjoyed their meal. I’ve heard the pizza is a ‘must try’ - so I can’t wait to get back for a few more taste tests."

"This is an OG restaurant and I know why its been around so long…. The food is fantastic. Friends and I had a bacon and mushroom pizza along with a side of penne alfredo and cheesy garlic bread. It was the perfect meal to end a long and fun day on the island. I suggest patio dining."