Pizza Suprema

"The very definition of a hole in the wall spot that hits way above its weight with the quality of its food. Reminds me of an old school Staten Island pizza shop. The specialty slices as well as the plain punch way above their weight. The personnel are always friendly. Never had a bad experience here."

"I ordered the Philly pizza and lost my mind with flavor and love. This is my new pizza joint! Gentlemen taking my order and at pickup was extremely polite and well mannered. Highly recommend this place!!!"

"Great delicious pizza. It definitely tastes fresh. The guy that took my order, he was really cool and polite. I would definitely go back there again because the flavors are really on point, this is truly Sicilian pizza. Only hiccup was the time, I was told about 20 minutes and ended up being 32 minutes but after seeing and tasting my pizza, I could not complain, that is right up there with the best I've ever had and you can't rush quality. Well baked, right amount of portions. That white pizza is amazing and the Mediterranean with the marinated tomatoes is unrivaled. The Greek salad was so good with that potato salad on top and the desserts were amazing, the limoncello cake especially was delicious, you can get the notes of lemon on that icing."

"Anything less then 4 stars is bias for one reason or another. I had the pleasure of ordering here for the 1st time tonight (8-13-21) and was pleasantly impressed! They got everything correct and everything tasted fresh. I’m convinced that with regards to successful pizzeria’s, quality will always produce longevity. Definitely gonna give this place another shot but completely different from what I ordered tonight. Consistently is another big key for me."