Cedar Key Pizza and Subs D Street, Cedar Key, FL 32625

"Very friendly people! Pizza was great! Will return."

"I know the owner of this establishment must be a proud person who wants to put out a good product and that's why I'm giving you 3 stars instead of 1. I wanted so badly to like your pizza. The web pics looked amazing, the pizza and garlic knots just were not. You're using frozen dough, most places do but you have to Thaw the dough ball in oil and it needs time to rise... Your pizza could be so much better if you simply let it proof. It isn't thin and crispy it isn't doughy, its underproofed, hard and not good. You can't get garlic knots out of the same under proofed dough... Listen you can do this but you need to ask for some help from your distributors on how to use the product. If you are buying from Sam's, just ask the Cafe folks how to do it. Your toppings are good, but you gotta fix the dough. I'm being honest with you because I am pro business and it's hard to make it with the storms and everything... Get some bread dough for your garlic knots cut THAT into pieces and do a garlic knot pull apart, hell you could use frozen biscuits but under proofed pizza dough with a little butter and parm is still underproofed pizza dough. Now the other stuff. Put a curtain up, nobody wants to see the back room a mess even if they are just picking up. I don't want you to be upset by this review. I don't know you, I just wanna see you do well and I promise if you fix the dough you will. Its bad man... Remember it doesn't cost anything to proof dough longer."

"I ordered a Philly cheese steak and my wife ordered a personal pan pizza.......this was one of the best cheese steaks I've tasted. My wife's pizza was incredible, this food was better than any chain restaurant."

"Calzone was delicious! Not sure where the ricotta was couldn't taste it. The husband got their meat lovers pizza and enjoyed it. Nice place to stop along on our vacation."

"Took a staycation to Cedar Key. Our first night we didn't feel like cooking and ordered pick-up from here and were not disappointed! The calzone was delicious & I loved the welcoming homy atmosphere when I picked up. *Edit: we got pick-up on our last night as well, we just couldn't do another clam dinner & I didn't want to cook. We got a sausage pizza and garden salad. The salad was the perfect size for two to share and the pizza was the bomb!"