Forefeathers - Chicken Madness 1624A East 16th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11229

"I've been waiting to try Forefeathers for a while after seeing all the positive reviews about it on Google, and I'm perfectly happy to say that not only do they not disappoint, but they surpassed my expectations. We got the Fries Madness and the 3 Piece Chicken Tenders thinking it wouldn't be enough, but I honestly think we bought enough for two more meals. The Fries Madness was absolutely delicious - the flavorful sauce with the combination of salad and fried chicken worked perfectly together. The chicken tenders were perfectly seasoned and were incredibly juicy. We got the Chipotle sauce and their homemade Garlic Parmesan sauce with them and they were super tasty; the homemade Garlic Parm sauce was especially creamy and flavorful as well. The banana pudding was also great - not too sweet, just the way I like it. Also shout-out to the front of house guy behind the counter. He had such a great demeanor and was such a great conversationalist. You can tell he is proud of the food that the kitchen produces, and that really got excited to try the food when we got home. Definitely coming back to this place and recommending it to others!"

"Got the Nashville Burger combo , customer service was impeccable and the best customer service you can get , guy at the front counter definitely needs a raise. The sandwich itself was good and had nice flavor to it. Place is clean and has great service , a spot to definitely go to when in the area (:"

"Lets start with the good! I ordered a Fries madness and a banana pudding, and they were very hospitable to me. I waited a bit for my order but only because I sat in a place directly underneath the counter and they did not see me. They have two vending machines in the lobby as well (either that or those kinds of similar refrigeration units, I don’t remember) When I got home, I opened up the box to see that my food was absolutely drowned with sauce. It was so bountiful I couldn’t even tell what I was looking at! The sauce taste was very good, has a mild spice to it but my sensitive gut made it a trip. (That’s just a skill issue though) The fries in fries madness were probably the least best element, they were nothing to write home about. I really liked their pickles, and there was of course chicken tenders as well as Mac and cheese in the meal. I ordered it without coleslaw and lettuce, and it was pretty good! It was such a big meal it took me the whole day to eat through I gave the banana pudding to my mom, and it was perfect for her as it was very soft and didn’t need too much chewing, she said she really enjoyed it Unfortunately, The store itself was a bit dirty due to prior customers not really throwing out their trash, as well as the trash bins there were full to the brim. I also think that they gave too many utensils and napkins for one meal, I think it would be a good idea to ask how many people you are ordering this for so the proper amount of utensils are being used as plastic is bad for the environment. I’m likely not to order fries madness again (However if you like spice and don’t have a high spice tolerance this is completely fine to eat!), but I definitely want to give their other meal items a go!"

"My gf has been loving a chicken sandwich that's executed properly. Forefathers Chicken Madness delivered 1000%. The manager is a very welcoming & humble family man. You can tell he puts his heart behind the products he serves. His crew are pushing excellent food. I had the hot chicken sandwich (regular heat). My gf had the double original chicken sandwich, it was stacked super high!. As a restaurant professional; this humble sandwich shop serves great food! Screw commercial chain come here and be satisfied! (Thank you for the Banana Pudding!) We will be back!"

"I recently had a pleasure of trying Nashville style fried chicken sandwich at Forefathers restaurant and I have to say, it was one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had! Chicken was perfectly cooked- crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. Not greasy at all and perfectly seasoned. It was perfect serves with pickles and coleslaw which perfectly balanced the spice with creamy element. Overall, I would highly recommend this place for anyone looking for delicious and satisfying meal. I can’t wait to try it again!"