Girolamo's Pizza

"As an Italian guy who grew up in Brooklyn and has missed great pizza since moving out west: Simply put, the pizza is absolutely fantastic. You don't even need toppings, the base product is just phenomenal. There's no upper limit on how many slices I can eat because it's just so good. This is the quintessential Brooklyn corner pizza joint. Girolamo is a cool, friendly guy and he works the counter himself. Can't recommend this place strongly enough."

"Excellent pizza. Thin crust. Good garlic rolls (fluffier than knots)."

"Girolamo's Pizza is the newest hotspot pizzeria in Gravesend/ Bensonhurst! My first encounter with Girolamo's Pizza I ordered for delivery. I was blown away by their pepperoni pizza. The quality, sauce, cheese and crisp of their dough was unlike anything I’ve had in a while. I’ve waited awhile to post this review because I really wanted to come and eat in. From the moment you step into their pizzeria, you're greeted with a simple yet inviting ambience. The open layout and ample seating create a warm and comfortable atmosphere. I ordered three spicy vodka slices. The burst of flavor from each bite was unlike no other. I’m simple when it comes to a homemade marinara sauce but this spicy vodka speaks volume! The slice was that good, I had to order three more to go. It's worth mentioning the owner, Jeremy, who adds an extra touch of charm to the pizzeria. With his knowledge, humor, and dedication to his business, he not only ensures that customers have a great dining experience but also creates a welcoming environment for everyone. Overall, Girolamo's Pizza impresses with its mouthwatering pizza, cozy atmosphere, reasonably prices, and the passion of its owner. It's definitely a place worth returning to again and again. Welcome to the neighborhood!"

"This cozy pizzeria is a clear depiction of Brooklyn family love! Their classic New York slice has dough that flawlessly crispy and cheese that is bubbly and gooey. I love the sauce on all the pies especially the spicy vodka! The Trifecta pie is a mix of marinara, vodka and pesto swirled to perfection. The rice balls taste just like mom’s!! Girolamo’s Pizza is definitely my new favorite place in Brooklyn!"

"Girolamo's Pizza is about to be the newest hot spot in Brooklyn. Get there before you can't get in the door. The pizza is your classic NY slice but elevated, fresh, delicious every time. The sauce and dough are perfection. From the NY Regular to the Spicy Vodka, you really can't go wrong. My advice get a slice of the Sausage and Hot Peppers and a couple of rice balls and garlic knots. The interior is inviting, you're going to want to hang out and order a second round of food."