Don Antonio

"This is one of the best pies in NYC. Great, super thin, wood fired Italian style pizza. The crust has the perfect balance of chewy airy bubbled dough and crispness. The toppings seem to be of great quality really upping the flavor. The posted pic is of the “Butcher” which has 4 meats separated into 4 separate slices. Mangia!"

"The pizza was excellent! It's not traditional NY style. It was mouth watering and super Italian gourmet. The service was also super good. My water was refilled constantly and the waitress consistently checked on us! Amazing dining experience! I highly recommend this spot!"

"Quiet pizza spot with a front door that you really need to push to open. Typical tight squeeze seating and the decor had a great appeal. Love the old New York City photos. Everyone working was very nice. Ordered two pizzas. First was the celebrated deep fried pizza topped with smoked mozzarella cheese. What an amazing combination. There were spots of cold sauce but still tasted great. The other pizza was with a nice selection of roasted vegetables. The pizza itself was underdone in the middle, very chewy, and hard to cut. Overall, great neighborhood spot for a small pizza in Hell's Kitchen. Make sure to get the Montanara pizza."

"5 stars only because of pizza. Fritto misto was so and so, tasted like 4 almost the same fried things... Mozzarella and prosciutto was good and pizza tartufo and capricosa excellent, cooked to perfection. No reservations, so it might be a bit of a wait. Service was good. If you don't loke crowded, noisy places and the fact that you eat so close to other guests you better be off"

"I'm going to go 5 star on Don Antonio though I'd say more 4.5. No question I'll be back and I'd bring friends. Narrow theater district sit-down brick oven pizzeria. It's tight quarters at the small place. They make 12" pies - no slices. Each pie is a bit more than 1 person can comfortably eat. We couldn't taste the difference between the buffalo mozzarella and regular mozzarella - enjoyed both. Suggest you split a pie and split an app or 2. Service is just ok. Friendly, but distracted. Busboy dripped on me and then wanted to lean over me again to fetch the red pepper flakes - I told him to leave it and wait until we're gone, but he couldn't! He had to awkwardly lean over me again!"