Autentico

"Dinner and dessert was good but the service…..not so much. You need a manager on the floor, not just waiters and busboys. No one asked about my appetizer or main course. No one asked if I wanted more wine. No one refilled my water glass. A restaurant needs equal amounts of good food, good service and a nice atmosphere. Autentico needs a little help. I’ll go back…..someday."

"Among the finest Italian fare to be had anywhere. This smallish spot in the heart of Oyster Bay just keeps delivering the freshest, most inspired dishes I've ever found. Eating here is a gastronomic treat not to be missed!"

"We celebrated my wife’s birthday at Autentico last night. Everything was superb and delicious. From the presentation to the taste, both dinner and dessert were fabulous! The Legendary Bolognese never disappoints. Service was kind courteous, and helpful in answering any questions we had about the menu. A truly memorable evening. Thank you."

"Cute little spot in Oyster Bay, with outstanding food and top-notch service. My date and I shared a meat & cheese platter for an appetizer, and then for the main course she got the veal ossobucco ravioli and I got the pappardelle Bolognese. Everything was delicious and so filling, but I made sure to save some dessert. I tried one of the dessert specials - a cannoli donut, and it was even better than it sounds. 10/10 would go again."

"It was not just a meal but an amazing culinary experience,a trip to the flavors and the tastes of Sicily. We really enjoyed food and felt the passion that chef Francesco puts in each dish. He is truly an amazing chef and I wanna thank him for preparing an absolutely extraordinary dinner for us."