Umberto's of Lake Grove

"I’ve been eating at Umbertos since this last summer, sat down, takeout and from DoorDash. Today I ordered from door dash and then I called and spoke to an employee and asked for the pie to be light cheese and well done. If I could post a pic I would but it was completely the opposite. So I went for the garlic knots that I ordered and they usually are the best around. How do you put 6 knots in a bag without any garlic on them ? Up until now I would drive the 10 mins myself to sit down or get takeout, never again and the kicker is I can’t blame DoorDash cuz I spoke to an employee !"

"Came here to try the vegan menu and really really enjoyed my vegan grandma pizza pie!! Ate the entire thing! Can't wait to return and want to try more! January 2024 update: great vegan Margherita!"

"An $18 salad with bad lettuce. First and last time ordering from here. Pure carelessness. Quality is not good at all and when I called all the guy kept saying was sorry sorry. Sorry doesn't fix it and if you are prepackaging you should pay attention to the lettuce which is the first to go bad in a salad."

"Stopped in for a slice just because they were the closest pizza to where we were staying in Lake Grove. Now I wouldn’t go anywhere else. The pizza slices were wonderful and the staff was so friendly. You can tell from the way the restaurant is taken care of that the owners are invested in its success. My only regret is that I did not ask to see all the available slices before ordering a cheese slice. The assorted pizzas are by the front counter. Next time I’ll ask and be more adventurous in my choice."

"The food and wines were incredible here! Probably one of the best pasta places I have been to till date. We arrived last night almost 15th a before their closing time. We were greeted well and were not rushed the entire time, which was great! While placing order, they served us some bread, garlic knots and butter (not great quality since the bread and knots were very hard). We started with some zucchini fries (very tasty, would appreciate if they were less oily). The marinara sauce served with the zucchini was very tasty and adequately flavored. They had options of ordering half plate pasta - which is a GREAT thing to do considering that way you can control your portions and sample more items. We ordered some Alfredo fettuccine (good), penne bolognese (tasty), penne Gamberi (loved it, so flavorful). The merlot and the dessert wine were good. The chocolate cheesecake was very good, not unnecessarily thick, appropriately sweet. Price wise it is moderate to towards high, ambience is decent. Overall I would have rated this place a 4 but the taste of the food made it a 5. Would love to try more of their dishes soon!"