Pontillo's Pizza Brighton

"Just ordered a pizza and some wings for dinner, awesome pie, wings were delicious! Delivery guy was courteous and polite, ty for a great quick dinner!✌️"

"If I could leave no stars I would . We ordered a pizza online for a delivery at 530 at 3:49. The first time we called at 545 asking where the pizza was they said it will be there in 10 - 15 mins . Now it's 615 no pizza so we called agian the same guy that answered the phone the first time suddenly says they don't have a order for us. We ask for a manager he gets on and says it'll be there in 20 mins ... we go thought you guys didn't have our order we want a refund instead . And he goes call back Monday for one. We said no we want one right now ..: then at the end of his convo he goes you should just go order from somewhere else . NICE BUISNESS yall should be closed . Your pizza sauce wacked anyways ."

"Very good pizza - staff was friendly a they got our special requests done right ! We got a large pepperoni and it was a bit pricey but it fed 3 people easily !"

"We ordered a pizza last night from Pontillo's Brighton. It was not good. It was a med with banana peppers and onions. The crust tasted like it was sitting around all day. The pizza tasted old and stale. We have had pizza from this loctaion before that was pretty good. Hot and fresh. Last night was not the case. I ordered pick up so when I got home I was not about to go back out. The most important think is getting a hot fresh tasting pizza."

"Not sure on the negative reviews, this was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Will surely be ordering again. This is the New Yorker - specifically order this."