Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria 75 Lake Avenue, Hilton, NY 14468

"Unfortunately this is another business that won’t make it in Hilton. I have been to many Salvatore locations and this by far is the worst. The first time I went, I ordered 2 subs on a Wednesday night. Myself and my girlfriend waited 45 minutes and then asked for an update on our order. We were told 5 more minutes. 20 minutes after that, I asked again. I was told that they didn’t even see my order. The girl at the desk proceeded to dig through the garbage to find it. She found it and then told me it should be ready in 20 minutes. An hour and a half we waited in the restaurant for only 2 subs. Cold subs by the way. Today, we tried again. Two subs, fries and pickle chips. Timing wasn’t bad. We ordered online this time. I called 30 minutes after ordering to verify that the food was ready. I was told 15 more minutes. No big deal, it’s a Friday night. I go to pick up the order and we are missing the pickle chips. Not fried pickles but pickle slices on the side for our subs. I was told that they don’t do that there and they could credit us the $2.00 in the next couple days. Really? You put pickles in a cup and take my $2.00, it can’t be much easier. I’m done with this location. The subs are ok but the management or lack of, is terrible and the employees need to be trained. I give it 1 more year max if the business stays run like this."

"I ordered 4 subs and an order of fries and they charged me for all. However once I got my order home I discovered an entire sub was missing from my order. This isn’t the first time it’s happened to me from this place either. I think their $10 Thursday sub deals are excellent but when I have to go back because a sub is missing it kind of ruins the family dining together. Their staff definitely needs to pay attention to their job."

"Ordered a pizza and 2 orders of wings. Pizza was decent. The wings were 2 different flavors, but they decided to put them in the same container. Brilliant. Not my favorite place in Hilton for pizza, but not the worse. Just remember to speak slowly and clearly when ordering."

"All of the Salvatore's Old-Fashioned Pizzeria locations are locally owned, and the owners are committed to bringing the finest selection of foods to your table. Pizza is always good at Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, Since 1978. It has been a long time coming, but it was so worth the wait. Thursday's daily deal can't be beat."

"We were excited to try Salvatore’s since it took so long to open, wait time for a large pizza was 45 minutes - 1 hour on a Wednesday. The dough seemed to have been sitting out for hours because it was extremely dry and inedible. Barely any sauce and the cheese was dark. With the over saturation of pizza joints in Hilton, we will not be returning for pizza."