Caraglio's Pizza 7 Main Street, Hilton, NY 14468

"You just can't beat Caraglio's Pizza. There are many different locations in the Rochester area, so pick the location that is the most conveniently located for you. The many types of pizza, wings and other items provides enough variety that there is something for everyone. Join their rewards program, and take advantage of daily deals. Monster Slices are always a great option."

"Took 10 minutes to heat up a piece of pizza that was made the day before , pizza was gross and the store is disgusting. I'll go to any other place next time I want pizza. Next order, 40 minutes late , couldn't cancel order and girl was rude."

"We had a bad day, today so we ordered from Caraglio’s. A Cappicola sub, a pulled pork sandwich and an order of onion rings. What we got was a sub with 2 thin slices of cappicola and a flattened cold pork sandwich, no onion rings. I called the store and spoke with the manager, who is the person who actually took the order and was told she never heard me say onion rings but she’d be happy to send me an order if I paid for it. Yeah, I’m going to wait another hour for onion rings…not. This was not the first screwed up order but you can bet it’ll be the last one. I’m done with you, goodbye!"

"Really good pizza, probably the best dough around. Constantly cooked perfectly. Great amount of toppings. They consistently make the pizzas smaller than advertised, and that isn't just this location. The one pictured is a large, which is supposed to be 16 inches, but closer to 15 1/4. I know that sounds picky, but that adds up to be a large area, especially when it happens every time. I'll still be back, but know what you're getting. The size discrepancy is worse on sheets."

"Great pizza and wings. They get extremely busy so don't be surprised if it takes your order one hour to be ready for pickup. Frankly, their pizza and wings are worth waiting for, just call well ahead just in case, particularly during big football events."