Adirondack Pizzeria

"As a born native in old Forge, the pizza was the best thing especially for the summer. I understand new ownership took over and when I got it Christmas Eve 2023 I open the box and was very disappointed. Crust was kind of burnt. It was very thin. It just wasn’t the same, my advice is , if Something that has been so popular for so many years, Why change it ? U have spoken to many locals that grown up with the pizza are very disappointed in the new pizza. It’s just a suggestion to try to go back to the way it was."

"I just stopped here while waiting for my coffee from blue line not expecting much. There was a sign on the door that stated new management. Anyways, I got two cheese slices and was pleasantly surprised!! I personally don’t like my pizza too saucy and whatever recipe they use, I loved it! Was not overpowering. Very thin NYC style pizza. Not super well done which I prefer but I know NYC pizza lovers like that charred crust. 5 stars from me !"

"LOVE Adirondacks/ Old Forge atmosphere, HOWEVER... Owner was unbelievably RUDE and annoyed that they were so busy! Seems to me that she should have been GRATEFUL and THANKFUL for those customers instead! Pizza was mediocre. Arcade area was cool, but could have been SOOO much better if all the games were actually working! It's obvious that they are absolutely taking advantage of an awesome, prime, tourist location! NOT worth it! Do yourself a favor and travel a bit down the road to Inlet and visit The Sreamen Eagle instead!"

"We were driving through Old Forge and stopped. So glad we did. It was great pizza and the kids enjoyed it. We will be visiting again."

"I don't think I can recommend stopping here but I sort of want to recommend it. It is so close to being great... but it just isnt. Let me explain first the food. It is bad the pizza is just sort of lifeless and rubbery with a little work it could be great but as it stands it's like eating bad school cafeteria pizza, everything else we had was fine perfectly as expected but the pizza was poor, and honestly I was not expecting a lot but just slightly above average. It is not above average. Then there is what should be a cool arcade... but nothing, around half of the games are broken or malfunctioning and they are the worst kind of sticky... they need cleaning badly. If they can manage to fix the pizza and the broken arcade machines, both of which wouldn't be that hard this place could be amazing and nostalgic but still be appealing. It's just a shame they haven't gotten those things sorted out."