Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

"This is a wonderful little pie shop. From the 4" sample box to the full size pies. Each more delicious than the last. We were lucky enough to be there for the new fall flavors. The Spiced Applebutter Pie was fantastic."

"Perfect size mini pies! Hubby tried I-40 and I tried strawberry, and we’re both pleasantly surprised how yummy these pies are. We are visiting the area for a short time & will definitely be back to try some other flavors. They also carry Meg’s Macs, which I confirmed after I’d left but next time I’ll be sure to get some because they’re some of the best macs we’ve had!"

"Bought 2 pies. The key lime was okay, tho a little too sweet but the strawberry was terrible. For $30 a pie, I expected much more. Strawberries were definitely not fresh. Like eating a sugary pure tasteless paste. Tried calling and emailing to return, no response after 1 week."

"Stopped in for the first (of what I’m sure will be many) time today! Cute and clean store. Friendly and helpful staff! And the two pies we got were SO good! We got the Key Lime pie and something called a Cloud 9 with the apple pie. We’ll definitely be back to try all of the different pies!"

"Haven't been inside, but I've had pies from this location's plenty. The pumpkin pie is by far the best pumpkin pie I've ever had and the appearance of their pies combines quality and creativity with homecooking. Some reviews may classify them as pricey, of what I'm assuming is only compared to a grocery store's pies? - but they don't compare. These actually taste like quality; it's not just a brand price tag. Super friendly staff, eager to assist which is rare these days. Overall = Amazing."