Old Mill Creamery

"We come to the Old Mill Creamery every time we visit the area! The Banana Pudding ice cream and Oatmeal Creme Pie Ice Cream are both AMAZING!!! This time we even purchased pints to take back to the cabin and enjoy!"

"The Old Mill Creamery is a well stocked ice cream shop with a super friendly staff. The stock a large variety of ice cream flavors as well as muffins and other delicious treats. There is also a very nice outdoor seating area with tables and chairs for the use of their customers."

"Went in for a scoop of ice cream for my daughter. Asked for a sample and girl behind counter was so unfriendly. She never spoke until I paid for the ice cream, when she told me the total. My daughter and husband thought the ice cream was delicious. The big problem came in when I went back in to buy bottles of water. A different girl was working the counter. When I went to pay, I saw the rude girl sitting in the back, eating a bag of funyuns, licking her fingers, and looking at her phone. The girl who waited on us asked the rude girl to help other customers. The rude girl proceeded to come out from the back and start waiting on people, giving out samples and scooping ice cream, without ever washing her hands. She was just LICKING HER OWN FINGERS! She was using the scoop, handing people ice cream samples, and touching cones and other food and giving it to patrons. I went outside, told my husband, and we threw away the rest of the ice cream. We were both so incredibly disgusted. That rude girl needs to be re-educated on basic hygiene and how germs are spread. Or she should just be outright fired because of the combination of her disgusting and disease-spread practices and her terrible customer service skills!"

"Our friends raved about this place, and that’s why we wound up here at 8:45 - 15 minutes before closing. All the flavors looked good, on the wall and in the freezer. There was a line, and I was hesitant to ask for a sample. But the three young ladies were sweet and patient. I decided on a scoop of Cookies & Cream and Vanilla Bean in a waffle cup. The cones looked too messy on a warm night. Husband had the banana pudding. He said it tasted like the pudding, but better! Mine was good, too. So good that I know we’ll be back. We sat outside on a bench in front of the store. We watched them put up the closed sign. And we watched large families come and look disappointed. The young ladies opened up the store for them, but at 9:05, with a long line inside, they put up the sign again. They wanted to clean up and go home on a Saturday night. But the few that got in were so appreciative. As I said before, and it bears repeating, this was our first time here. It won’t be our last."

"This place is outstanding! Great for a quick dessert or snack if visitng the Old Mill shoppes. You can sample the ice creams before purchasing. Has made from scratch goodness. Ordered the kid's cup since I was so full from lunch. Had bear paw ice cream which was made with chocolate and caramel mixed together. A perfect combination! You can get sundaes here as well. Check the menu board for their current offerings. Definitely a great way to cool off on a hot day!"