The Original NY Pizza

"If you are thinking about it, go! I stopped in while shopping in the area and had some of the most authentic NY pizza I’ve had in the area. Great crust, perfectly balanced and cooked. Traditional cheese, garlic knots and a Buffalo chicken pizza all were great!"

"I've lived all over the country including NYC and very rarely do you find exceptional pizza. This is one of the few. They don't just use mozzarella cheese on their pizza but other Italian cheese. The puzza sauce is excellent though not the best I've had. I would very strongly recommend this place in Cary. You guys are lucky to have such a place as this. 5/5"

"I used to buy a lot of pizza from this place. I don’t know if they have changed ownership, but the pizza has sucked lately. I asked for extra sauce, I got half. They were almost no toppings on the pizza, I ordered four. It is consistently undercooked. I don’t know if they punish you for using your rewards or not, but this last pie was the last pie."

"Stopped by this place for the first time after seeing it here on Google and reading reviews. Sometimes there are places that claim to be NY pizza but its kind of gimmicky. Thin crust and a metric ton of oil just doesn't constitute a good NY slice. Pizza here was paper thin, the cheese, really good, the gravy, not excellent but not bad. Overall I would say that this NY place is NOT a gimmick. I enjoyed the slices and will return for full pies and try out some other menu items. Service was okay, I don't like when people do not talk much and there seemed to be some awkwardness or tension between the three people working in front. I don't know, maybe it was just a bad day and everyone is entitled to their own. I will revisit and then revise my review soon."

"I bet this would have been one of the best cheese pizzas in Cary that delivers if it had arrived freshly hot! 4 stars only because it was barely warm and took an hour on a Sunday night. Great flavor and good crust. Will remember them next time I'm in town."