Catch Steak New York

"Food was decadent and over the top, but service was abysmal. When I pay that much for food, if the kitchen is backed up, I expect at least an acknowledgment or an apology. The manager said “if you order your steak well done, it takes 45 minutes to prepare”. The only problem is that everyone in our party ordered their steak medium rare or medium. Went for a birthday dinner and we asked if they could put a candle in one of the three pieces of cake we ordered… they put in the candle but didn’t light it. Seated at 8:45… didn’t pay our check until after 11:30 pm… and not by choice. Main courses didn’t come out until after 10:45. The food was delicious… cheese pulls for days in the decadent Mac n cheese. Steak was well seasoned and cooked perfectly, albeit stingily portioned. Waffle fries were crisped to perfection. Hyped prices for Outback service. Won’t go back."

"Very nice atmosphere, very good service, every dish was full of flavor and absolutely delicious. A bit expensive but worth the price. 5 stars"

"Great restaurant. The service was excellent. The ambiance was great, a little noisy but overall fun. The food is of good quality. A little bit overpriced but at the end of day I think it compensates with the service excellence. Big Recommend."

"It was a beautiful place, especially on New Years Eve. They decorated it so beautifully and made sure that all the guest received NYE items to welcome in the new year. The drinks were also amazing as well. They offer wonderful service."

"While visiting NYC I had been in some Tourist areas that were extremely crowded and I’d had enough of the crowds. I asked some locals “Where do the locals go?” Catch Steak was suggested to me so I made reservations, then decided to read the reviews. After reading some of the reviews I almost cancelled my reservations bc a few said staff was rude and food wait was long. I decided to go and form my own opinion. My experience was quite different from the negative reviews. When I walked in I was greeted with a warm welcoming. I arrived early for my reservations bc I wasn’t sure of traffic times. I was asked if I’d like to check my coat in while I dined, which I thought was great! since I was early I was offered a seat at the bar for a cocktail till my table was ready. Although I was early and sat at the bar to have a cocktail, I didn’t have the time to finish it before my table was ready. I was seated 15 min early. The wait staff was really friendly, attentive and offered great suggestions. My food came out in a timely manner, was excellent and worth the price I paid and the experience I had. The managers even came around checking on me as well as other patrons in the restaurant. I observed the staff working together helping each other out. I was impressed to see management pouring water if the noticed a glass was getting low and making sure each table was taken care of. One review said no photos could be taken, so I asked about that. I dined alone and wanted a picture in there and the staff was happy to take my picture. When I questioned about that the manager told me they don’t allow flash photography. Needless to say I was happy to have gone and form my own opinion of Catch Steak! It was a very pleasant experience. I ordered the catch roll as an appetizer, truffle butter filet, crab and the Brussel sprouts. I ordered an amaretto sour for my cocktail. Outstanding food."