D.J. Reynolds,

351 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

"The worst Irish coffee in my life ! A very average meal ... but the worst Irish Coffee in my life ! A huge delay to get our food was a bit weird seeing as there were few eating .. but have you ever seen an Irish coffee where you fill the glass to the top with coffee, you then poor in a touch of whisky and then you add spray cream ? Seriously, for that price that's ridiculous ! And when you are a super bar man you don't mesure the quantity... so there isn't any taste of whisky! I didn't even finish it but fled as quickly as possible !"

"We stopped by for a quick drink before dinner. The single server was doing his best to keep pace working a 30-40% full room. The major issues were entirely with the bartender. She was more interested in flirting with the guys at the end of the bar than pouring our drinks. Took 5 minutes to get at white wine, another 15 to get two mixed drinks and we never got a draft beer. Further she poured one of the drinks as a vodka + ginger ale instead of Jack + ginger ale that was ordered. Then she was confused when we sent it back, despite the fact that it looked more like water than whiskey. Will not be back. Wouldn't recommend."

"Good neighborhood bar/restaurant. If sitting at the bar, don’t sit at the bar seats by the door because the curve of the end bar is at an awkward radius where you can’t rest your arms or elbows on the bar comfortably. Bathrooms are clean. They have Smithwicks and Guinness on draft"

"Came in around 10ish and ordered food and drinks. Food was really good and hot. Cocktails were very well prepared. Service was outstanding and friendly. Also, I was thrilled that the noise level was reasonable. Not too loud, making it easy to hold conversations. Definitely coming back."

"A midtown treasure! I absolutely love D.J. Reynolds. I recently came here with my dad who was visiting from out of town. After a visit to a museum and a walk around the Time Warner Center, we had lunch at D.J. Reynolds. It was a Friday afternoon and we were able to find a table. The staff here is SUPER friendly and welcoming. I had the buffalo chicken wrap whereas my dad had the lunch special - beef stir fry. Both dishes were served with generous proportions. I'll definitely return!"