The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House 1201 East Bay Avenue, Stafford Township, NJ 08050

"Reasonable good food but not the best. Not much of seafood selection. The restaurant next door mud city is superior but closed in winter."

"I recently had dinner at the Old Causeway Stake and Oyster House. The place was fairly crowded with a bar like atmosphere and karaoke happening in the front room. The menu has an extensive selection of seafood, steaks and burgers. Service was good. My father had the Ruben and I had the steakhouse burger. Both were the cheapest thing on the menu at 18$. It seems to just be a really expensive place for the atmosphere. The burger was okay. It was a bit large and hard to eat with the avocado, egg, bacon and the texas toast. The sauce was abundant and the burger was salted as well. I wasn't able to eat the entire thing in one sitting and it didn't reheat particularly well. The coleslaw was just cabbage and vinegar."

"I recently dined at The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster house it was casual yet high-quality steakhouse that exceeded my expectations. The inviting atmosphere seamlessly blended with a top-notch dining experience. The star of the show was undoubtedly the perfectly cooked steak and lobster, showcasing the establishment’s commitment to quality. Beyond the food, the vibrant bar scene added an extra layer of enjoyment, and the live music enhanced the overall ambiance. This steakhouse strikes the ideal balance between casual dining and culinary excellence, making it a standout choice for those seeking a memorable and relaxed evening out in LBI"

"I am from the midwest and was recommended this place by a kind toll worker. I was impressed right away! I walked in and everyone was kind and friendly... employees and patrons alike. Everyone who worked here seemed to really enjoy working with one another, which can be rare to witness, but it made me smile! I sat at the bar both times and was helped right away. The atmosphere has an old world feel, but clean. There is a large cosmonaut suit on display and the bar has four televisions for your sport viewing. It also has seating for families and groups larger than 3+ to dine. The food was great! I came two different times on my trip... The first time I ordered the fried olives and something with as much seafood in one sitting as one could get... afterall, I am right off the coast and seafood is a natural resource here. The Seafood Pot (images below)is what I decided on. Both were delicious & filling! The second time I ordered, I saw someone else eating... Corned Beef Reuben with Parmesan Shoestring Fries & ordered that! I was not disappointed... So good! The bread was a little on the crispy side, but it was not a deal breaker. I recommend eating here!"

"And old favorite for sure. Usually in season you have to fight for a happy hour spot but local summer has come through again and the place is peaceful to enjoy the first eagles game of the season. The food is exceptional and the service is fast and efficient. Always a delicious spot."