Atco Pizza & Cafe (Formerly Sally Starr Pizza)

"We can’t get enough of this place, the pizza is perfect. I know no one likes to live in shadows of previous businesses but we gave this place another try after they went under new ownership. We were not fans of Sally’s originally. So happy that pizza is just a skip and a hop down the road from us that is now GOOD! Can’t wait to try out breakfast one day. The staff is super friendly and accommodating as well. Give it a try if you haven’t already :)"

"Very clean and welcoming when you walk in. We got a cheesesteak and a meat lovers pizza. Arrived when it should have been done and it was another 10 minutes with no one else waiting. The desserts look great and was told they are made in house. I did not try them this time. The pizza was a perfect mix of the cheese and meats and not just meats piled on haphazardly. I would definitely get it again."

"I originally meant to post this review in December, but you know how crazy December can be. The first time we called for delivery, it was the Friday after the new menus were delivered in the mail and it was pouring rain. The lady who answered the phone asked if we were calling about a new order or existing order. I said new and she kindly asked if we could call back in 45 to an hour to place our order. I laughed and said that everyone must’ve had the same thought we did. She laughed also and said they were overwhelmed and humbled by the amount of people who had called. We were very hungry and decided to call back another time. The next time, we ordered the hand tossed pizza with pepperoni and wings. Delivery was timely and the pizza was one of the best we’ve had since we moved to Atco 4 years ago. The crust to sauce to cheese ratio was perfect. The sauce was delicious and the crust had a nice crumb to it. Not dry at all. The wings were good, but not the best we’ve had. We tried the hot sauce and Tony’s famous. Both were very good. Tonight, I ordered the cobb salad, chicken noodle soup, and garlic bread. The salad was incredibly fresh and they do not skimp on the toppings! Very important to me. The balsamic vinaigrette was also delicious. The soup is just like grandma would make. The order of garlic bread is a big portion. Enough for 2-3 people. Very good experiences. Definitely recommend."

"Took the entire family to breakfast Sunday including those visiting for the holidays - that’s 12 people at once. All the food came out hot, at the same time, and everyone said their meal was very good. We’ve been for dinner as well on two occasions and the service and food were just as good. Desserts are made on site by the owner (who loves to show them off) and they’re very good! His wife makes the soups and those in my family that are soup people praised them as well. The rest of the menu is like a scaled down diner menu that still provides a good selection of options (I’m not originally from up here in yankee land so seeing 5000 items on a diner menu still gets me). Since the decision to sell Sally Starr’s by the old owners brought about the change, I’m glad that what’s come to the area is still family friendly and a really good restaurant."

"I think the reviews for this place are heavily skewed as they carried over from Sally Stars. Food was edible - that’s about the best I can say. We got their menu attached to our front door and decided to give it a try, but I guess they got more business from that than they were expecting? We ordered delivery and my confirmation said it’d be 30 minutes, so after an hour passed I called the restaurant. The guy who answered the phone was nice enough but said they were slammed and orders were taking awhile. Totally cool, I get it! But he sounded like he didn’t even have my order put in or anything yet. He had to keep asking my name and then said it’d be out shortly so it felt as though it never made it to the kitchen but I could be wrong. By the time it arrived it was like 2 hours after we had placed the order and we didn’t get the 2 liter soda we ordered but it was such a hassle getting our food that we didn’t even bother calling back. I got the flounder wrap and there was hardly any fish, mostly just breading. My grandfather got the eggplant parm with spaghetti and a salad. He ate it all so he didn’t hate it!"