Pop-Pop's NY Pizza

"Ordered out, delivery was reasonable. Ordered the Carne Asada Tacos, just terrible. The meat is what looks like "steak-umms", and has no flavor what so ever, even with the hot sauce, cilantro and onions. After 2 tacos I threw it out, couldn't stomach the 3rd one. Rice and beans were just ok. Won't be ordering Mexican food from an Italian Restaurant again."

"I’m giving one star because I have to leave a star to comment. I ordered a large pizza, fried calamari and a cup of hot honey to drizzle on my pizza. The pizza came and it was ice cold and rubbery like it sat out all day and the calamari was like chewing on rubber… literally!! I don’t even think the calamari was fried, I think they microwaved it from frozen. The cup of honey they charged $1.50 extra and wasn’t even enough to drizzle on one slice. A waste of $41, never again will we order there. My 3 year old son wouldn’t even eat the pizza and he loves pizza."

"I recently had the pleasure of trying Pop Pop’s Pizza for the first time, and I must say, it was an extraordinary experience. My taste buds were treated to the delightful combination of flavors in the half Birria and El pastor pizza - an absolute culinary masterpiece! I'm not one to usually write reviews, but the outstanding quality of the food and the exceptional service compelled me to share my thoughts. Initially planning to take the pizza to go, the warm and inviting demeanor of the staff convinced us to dine in. The cook and the waitress were not just professionals, but genuinely caring individuals who made our evening truly special. Their kindness made us feel like we were right at home. It's rare to come across a place where both the food and the people create such an unforgettable experience. Pop Pop Pizza has earned a permanent place in our hearts as our new family pizza spot. Kudos to the team for their dedication and passion in delivering an exceptional dining experience."

"Place is the perfect hidden gem. One of those places you try once and hope it’s around for the rest of your life. The Al pastor pie is so amazing, I immediately told everyone I know about it and recommended they try it. Fantastic all around experience!"

"Was really hopeful about this pizza. Flavor was good, but the crust on the "thin crust" Sicilian was too tough to chew. Not crispy or burnt. It was just kind of stale and was hard to rip through. My wife said the crust was too hard to chew. We're going to try to reheat later to see if it'll crisp up. HUGE garlic knots which we enjoyed. It was a friday night at 8:30, so we'll try another day and time for the next pie."