Sea Bright Pizzeria & Restaurant

"Worst pizzaria in 46 years. First, the customer service is poor. The counter help was not friendly, and failed to tell me it was cash only until the pizza was already in the oven. I would never have ordered if I knew this. Then I told him he should have a sign up to tell customers and this is a highly important issue. He just ignored. The pizza is half the size of a regular pizza slice and twice as much. I know it's Seabright and all but damn I just paid 10 dollars for 2 half slices. I still would have been fine with all of this if the pizza was good but low and behold the pizza was cold. I was the only person eating in the restaurant. It almost felt like it was on purpose. By this time I was so annoyed I brought the pizza up the counter and left it there barely touched. This place was an insult. Don't waste your dignity or pocketbooks on this place."

"After 15 yrs of enjoying one of the best grandmas pie mine today tasted like cardboard! Called to express my experience they couldn’t care less! Maybe new owners certainly can’t b the same! Wasted $27!"

"I called for a grandma pie & I wanted to try the Christian pie too so Cono mentioned let’s do half & half!!! Wow that Christian pie was out of the park, love that it’s double zero dough, the best for you & amazing taste, the best of the best!! So enjoyed!! IT’S JUST PERFECTION!! Molto Grazie Cono, you are one of a kind!!"

"If I could give this place -5 stars I would. I walk in with my family, being the first time here. I asked the man behind the counter how they sell their pizza? He replies in squares and triangles. So I said OK we will take three slices of squares. He charges us $15. I then asked how much is a whole pie? He replies $25. I said then I will take a whole pie for just $10 more. He takes the money rings the sale, then nonchalantly tells me that it will take 30 minutes for a whole pie. i replied, then why didn't you tell me that before you rang the sale? He rudely answered me in an obnoxious way in front of my young children telling me that he told other people ahead of me that it was gonna take 30 minutes for a pie and I should have listened. I then said well you didn't tell me and I would never have ordered it if it was gonna be a 30 minute wait. So I said just give me the 3 square slices right now instead. He throws the 3 slices at me and doesn't give me back the difference until I asked him for it. The attitude, the rudeness, and the overall service was something that I haven't seen in quite a while. Not to mention the taste of this pizza. I wouldn't even give it one and a half stars, especially after we regularly eat at Vic's Pizza in Bradley Beach which blows this pizza away, not to mention their outstanding customer service. In running a business customer service is number one. I would never recommend this place to anyone I know, and would actually go out of my way to make sure people that do go there, stay away."

"July 2023: Grandma’s buffalo chicken and eggplant pizza is a must try. Cash Only!"