Gotham Pizza,

1443 York Avenue, Manhattan, New York 10075

"Great pizza. Very thin & crispy pizza. Bottom of pizza is a bit textured with crunchy bits which makes it stand out from other pizza places. Costs a few dollars more for a large pie compared to local places. Lunch deal is the best, 2 slices and a soda can for only $5!"

"Gotham Pizza has the best value lunch special in the neighborhood: 2 slices of cheese pizza and a drink, all for $5. And because they get so many orders of it, you’re guaranteed to have it freshly made."

"While not my favorite on the Upper East Side, the pizza here is pretty good. I had a slice of the Margherita pizza and an order of the garlic knots. They did not provide any sauce with the garlic knots. The pizza was good, but the garlic knots were just okay. They were on the small side and kind of hard. I don’t think they were fresh. They accept cards here."

"First timer to try the pizza. Always go with a cheese slice to establish a baseline. If they can't do that right then don't bother. Since I was very hungry I grabbed a pepperoni slice also. Went back for two more pepperoni slices. The cheese slice was a solid 3.5 but the pepperoni bumped it up to a 4. Add a nice cold can of Pepsi ( might have been Coke) and this is a good pizzaria. Not the mythical 5 star slice that I'm searching for but worth it if you around York Ave."

"I love this pizza spot. I've had some of the best Margherita pizza here. The Margherita pizza tastes and smells just as good as it looks! The workers are very kind and even offered to make my slice crunchier. It's pretty popular around 1230ish. Will be returning!"