Siena Pizza,

14 Rector St, New York, NY 10006, United States

"Was here on New Years Eve, just a couple days ago, and grabbed a slice and two cannolis (tiramisu and classic) to go. One of the BEST decisions I’ve ever made! I had the hot honey pizza slice, and I wish I got two! I’d travel back to New York for this pizza alone. The most amazing dough, sauce, and flavours. My friends and I have been craving this since we left. And the cannolis - especially the tiramisu one, in my opinion, were incredible!! The staff that helped us were very friendly and made sure we got what we were looking for and had us leaving feeling happy & like locals! 10000/10"

"Took a shot for my first night and was definitely worth it! I got the pepperoni square and nonna pizza both worth it! Also went back for a couple of cannolis and a Tiramisu and they knocked it out of the park! 10/10 recommend!"

"on vacation and stopped here for lunch about a week ago and the pizza was fantastic! had a couple of squares that were loaded with peperoni. great crust and sauce ! this place is not very big but we did get to sit at the window and eat. the staff was friendly and the restaurant was clean. great NY pizza !"

"The pizza here was pretty tasty. They only had pepperoni square pizza, not pepperoni slices which is interesting. The service was friendly and I received my food quickly. Customer service was inviting and there were a few places to sit which was nice! It’s worth a try especially if you’re in that particular area. Not a place I would necessarily travel miles for."

"Both the Classic Cheese and Square Pepperoni pizzas were really good. It's not the best pizza I have had in New York City, but it's really good for the price. There was also inside seating available, and the line to order was short. I would definitely recommend Siena Pizza if you are close and looking for a quick slice of pizza."