Tony's Pizzeria 59 Pacific Street, Newark, NJ 07105

"The pizza is good.....IF IT EVER GETS HERE HOT. Last 2 orders, first took 2 hours, the last took 1 hour 40 mins. Pizza cold by the time it got here. They say "It will be there within an hour" when you order. Lies. They are about 15 mins from my house."

"My wife placed an order for delivery today about an hour ago .The order was an egg salad sandwich and 2 slices of buffalo chicken pizza. The food was delivered and I began to eat the sandwich however my wife did not eat immediately and placed the box of pizza in the oven because she had other responsibilities to tend to. About 20 minutes later we received a call from Tony’s pizza and was inquired about if we received the pizza. My wife informed the lady that yes she did receive the pizza and as the conversation went forward she began to state that there was a mistake and she was delivered the wrong food. My wife reassured her that yes she had the box pizza but she didn’t know what pizza was in the box ( mind you my wife ordered 2slices of buffalo chicken pizza and the delivery driver mistakenly gave my wife a box of pepperoni pizza.. my wife doesn’t eat pork so that definitely wasn’t for her ) but the woman over the phone was making implications of some type of petty deception, saying “well you know that you didn’t order that pizza and my driver did delivery it to you “ . But was deaf to the fact that my wife repeatedly told her that the pizza was in the oven and had not been touched and we can make the exchange. The lady over the phone was very disrespectful and did not take accountability for the mistakes her driver made and the accusations and implications that she made. She was very smug and I am trying to wonder what warranted that. It’s ok.. that business just lost a customer, and long standing customer, who has been buying pizza from them since the real owner (Pepe) had the parlor. I don’t/won’t recommend them to anyone."

"Ordered a large Sicilian from these guys last night. I'll try and kick off on a positive and say that the sauce was fine. Ultimately though, generally a disaster. There was WAY too much base. I get that a Sicilian is meant to have a deeper crust but this was beyond that, something that was partly caused by the consistency of the base. This wasn't the chewy, oily deliciousness you're looking for from a Sicilian - the sauce and cheese sat on a kind of inflated bready mattress of a base, which seemed to have risen out of control, giving it the character of a loaf of bread that had pizza topping. The crust overload overwhelms the flavor of the pizza as opposed to complementing it the way it should. So you wind up bloated but without that "god damn I'm full but I'm full of pizza and that is awesome" feeling - instead you feel more like you've been stuffed with bread. Sorry to be harsh, calling it like I saw it (ate it?). I'd say reduce the depth of the crust but something is further awry in the process here that is making it, besides way too deep, also bland and even tasteless in flavor."

"The bacon cheeseburger was very good and recommended if you want a very tasty, high quality burger and fries. Also, the zeppoli Italian donuts with cannot cream in them were out of this world good. I never had them before and would go out of my way for them. There local delivery to my hotel was great and thanks to the hotel front desk for recommending them. I would definitely go try pizza and other sandwiches next time I am in the area."