The Sherwood Inn 305 North Main Street, New Salem Borough, PA 17371

"We had an excellent dinner. The new york strip steak was cooked to perfection. The soups were very tasty as well. Our server was the best. Angelina was professional, friendly and very knowledgeable of the menu. Can't wait to try the prime rib on my next visit."

"Update(2024): This used to be one of my favorite local places to go, but it's not my first choice anymore. I gave them leeway during Covid, but there's still no improvement in quality from the kitchen over the past year. --- Great local hangout spot. Only Bar in town. The majority of the food is good to great. Casual, inviting, and comfortable. The frozen cocktails are delicious! You can't go wrong with most food items and daily specials. If you order fries, ask for the beer fries. One item I don't recommend is the NY strip. It was overcooked and bland. Char was visually nice. Ordered medium but was given nearly well done. I'm not one to waste food so I ate it anyway. For the price, I expect better attention to flavor. (Update 2024) A new annoying thing is the kitchen makes substitutions without first communicating it to the customer. As an example, I recently ordered mexi fries, which on the menu lists " french fries, seasoned ground beef, cheddar Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, salsa." The dish I received had cheese sauce instead of cheddar Jack cheese, no lettuce, added jalapenos, and no salsa. The first staff person I notified blew me off time. That's the way they make it, and the second person went to the kitchen and got me lettuce and salsa. Either way, it was difficult to swallow because the meat was really dry and I hate cheese sauce. I would have never ordered this if I knew that's what I was getting differed from the menu."

"Seems like a pretty popular spot, it was pretty full when we got there. Service was pretty good, didn't have to wait too long for drinks. Ordered chili and cream of crab, both were good. Then i ordered 9oz new strip w baked potato and asparagus and gf ordered jacked up burger. Steak was pretty good, the temperature was PERFECT. My only complaint about this place is that it can be a little loud at times, but that's normal for a popular restaurant. Would definitely recommend and we will be back"

"Nice spot. Well kept. Didn’t try the food but took photos of current menu."

"The Inn offers both great and differing atmosphere, depending upon whether you’re sitting inside or on the outside deck. We were on the deck. The service was fantastic. Renee was very attentive and helpful. The drinks were wonderful. We enjoyed all three types of crushes — orange, grapefruit and watermelon. The Totchos were a perfect app. And the Rockfish Tacos and Greek Salad were fantastic. To finish and to celebrate my wife’s birthday, we enjoy a decadent, house made, peanut butter pie. I offer my highest recommendation!"