Muttley's | Downtown 438 William Avenue, Davis, WV 26260

"Muttley's has been closed for at least a couple years. I'm not sure why google still has it listed, but you can't go there. When it was open, it was a go-to place for us. I do not personally know this to be true,but I have been told that it was due to illness and/or death. Muttley's was a unique gem where we made many memories. I gave it all 1s because they are closed. When they were open, it was all 5s."

"Was not disappointed in stopping in for dinner here, especially on a Wednesday which happened to be burger night. We both had well done burgers with bacon, mushrooms, and roasted red peppers. Delicious and juicy, not to mention hot off the grill. Our waitress was very sweet and attentive. Loved that old time restaurant vibe. It was like stepping back in time. Yes, as others have mentioned the bathrooms are small, but hey!, that's not a place where one eats their meals. LOL Quiet dining to relax in after hiking and sightseeing as noise level is moderate."

"Great steakhouse! Friendly service. Theme on the wall art is old time western movies -William S. Hart and others. Very interesting! And they have potato ramp soup! The New York strip was perfect!"

"Historic building so it was a bit warm. Dont worry about large portions because that is not the case here. The salad that comes with the entrees is tiny, good stuff but tiny. I had the housemade balsamic and my hubby the housemade parmesan dressing, both very good. Entrees say they come with choice of vegetables my choice was french fries or brussel sprouts with kale. I cannot do fries so I got the upcharged portabella mushrooms which were ok, a bit salty. Never heard fries considered a veggie before. The peppercorn filet was tender well cooked pepper is strong, would have liked more of the bleu cheese sauce. Hubby was happy with his fettuccine alfredo."

"Food wasn't prepared as you would expect when paying for a meal which is in a price range from $16-$30 per plate. Steak was cooked in a pan, and undercooked-not as ordered. For the price of the steak, it should be grilled. Service was poor, prices for meals were way too high for what was being offered. I ordered the pasta and it was a heated up pasta dish and sauce that was pre-packaged. Very disappointing and expensive."