DiCarlo's Pizza - Glen Dale 1720 Wheeling Avenue, Glen Dale, WV 26038

"What has always set DiCarlo's apart from other pizza is the cold (unmelted) cheese on a crisp hot crust. The pizza I got there today had melted cheese on a soggy crust. It appears they made it ahead of time and put it in a warm oven. It was terrible! I recommend that you don't use a delivery service like DoorDash which I believe is the reason they made the pizza ahead of time and ruined it."

"Polite and professional staff, food was made fresh so it took 15 minutes from order to plate but was worth it.. there are eights chairs at 2 tables.."

"I did not order this “pizza.” I did not eat this “pizza”. My wife ordered this “pizza”. My wife loves this “pizza”. With that said I have eaten pizza from this diCarlos in the past. It’s the best version of the cold cheese pizza in WV. Of course it might be the only version of it in WV. It’s not the depression or the 1979 oil crisis. You can use some fossil fuels to melt the cheese. ;) You should try this “pizza”."

"This is a classic spot and a must when you are in the area. One place I always order from no matter how long I am in town for. I love the pizza and it OSS one of the few that can be heated in your oven the next day and still have that crispy flaky crust and taste just as good as it did when it’s fresh."

"Ok, I know that most people in Glendale and Moundsville love DiCarlo's after all it's been here for a long time but, I find that it just depends on whose working because sometimes it's not so great. The last time I got pizza there, which was a couple of weeks ago, the pizza was not good. The sauce was very spicy and the cheese was half melted and half raw and the crust was burnt. I hate where they are located at because it's hell getting out of there due to the traffic and I usually have to wait until there's no traffic so, I can pull out.They should of bought the Pizza Hut building, it has plenty of parking spaces and you don't have to wait to pull out. I'm not saying that I have stopped going there, I'm just saying they are not my favorite place to get pizza because you just don't know if it's going to be good."