Isaac's Restaurant - South York

"I got the Finch and it was very good. The only reason I gave this review 4 stars is because the broccoli salad was dry and because the hostess asked us if we wanted the pickle appetizer but never brought it and didn't convey to our server that we wanted it. The restaurant is clean, and it was a good atmosphere. They didn't have the twisted chicken anymore but you can build your own sandwich so it worked out ok anyway. The pepperjack tomato soup was amazing as always! Our server was good, attentive and helpful."

"Placed an order for pick up and came after closing (not realizing they were closed) and Mike was extremely accommodating and kind despite us keeping him there late. He’s a keeper!"

"We were seated promptly upon walking in to the restaurant around NOON on SATURDAY, and only saw one other table occupied. We began to look at the menus to make our lunch decisions. We sat there for approximately 10-15 minutes while several workers stood around and talked to one another behind the counter, and no one came over to greet us or take our orders. We walked out and went to another restaurant down the street. Don't think we'll be back to this one."

"I would love to take the chance to share my horrible experience. When I came into the restaurant I was overwhelmed by the menu and had no idea what to get. I asked a young lady of the name Lauren for help. She was nothing but rude to me. When I first asked her what was good on the menu, she told me, “you have eyes look yourself.” She continuously belittled me and was nothing but rude. I ended up getting a salad. The salad would’ve been good if the service from Lauren was better. I am definitely never coming back and recommend that the company fires her immediately. Never in my life have I been treated like this at a restaurant before."

"My husband and I ate here for lunch recently. It was 11am and just open. It was very clean and fast. I had the salty eagle with broccoli salad and my husband had the mallard. Love the pretzel rolls! Love the complimentary pickles. They are so good! We haven't been here for a long while but it was good as ever!"