Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant

"Traveling, my first time in Matamoras. Not sure where to eat, pick this place based on the recommendation of a hotel clerk at the Best Western. It did not disappoint. I sat at the bar and watched the World Series as I ate. The food was delicious! People were friendly and attentive. The place I sat was a bit drafty, being too close to the door, but I could have asked for a table. Pictured fish is penne pasta with red clam sauce. Absolutely delicious! Highly recommended."

"BEST pizza I’ve ever had I just moved to the area tried a few pizza places but they were all of that thin soggy pizza. THIS PLACE HAS THICK ROBUST PIZZA!!!! So beautifully crafted. THE GRALIC KNOTS ARE NOT DRY AT ALL. I will be coming back here a lot. They always have a bar which is very cool. Everything is definitely worth the price."

"There were 4 of us who went to eat around 730pm on a Friday night.We walked in and were sat immediately. The tables were full and they were a bit busy. We got our drinks and looked at the menu. There is food on there for everyone. Vegetarian to a meat lover. Our waitress wasn't the friendliest, but I think they were short staffed. Two of the people ordered pizza..one ordered a meat lovers roll, I got creamy parmesan rice pilaf with shrimp. We all enjoyed our food. You get a lot of it for your money! The slices are like 2 regular slice pizzas in one. The personal size pizza is a regular medium pizza,and the roll is like a calzone but in roll form, and everyone knows what rice pilaf is. Pictures show what I'm talking about."

"Goodfellas Pizza Italian Restaurant in Matamoras, PA, delivers a delicious experience reminiscent of its cinematic namesake. With an extensive menu featuring a variety of mouthwatering Italian dishes and, of course, pizzas, the restaurant offers a genuine taste of Italy. Great place for a last minute dinner if you prefer to not cook."

"This restaurant is a mistake. If I could, I wouldn't give any stars. We ordered pizzas. Some of the order came immediately and some after 45 minutes. The pizzas were so-so. But I have never encountered such service in any restaurant before. "An older woman with probably yellow hair was serving us. From the very moment we entered, she was very unpleasant and rude. I congratulate the owner on the choice of staff. She should leave her rude behavior at home. We didn't leave there because the kids ate their pizzas, although we should. But we will never go there again, even though we live in the area. I tell my friends to avoid this place. After eating pizza chicken alfredo, we spent the whole Saturday afternoon in the toilets. Nightmare. You run a very bad restaurant with a very bad waitress (old woman). How dare you write that my opinion is fictitious???. You have no idea how to run a restaurant!! You take care of this unpleasant person and don't waste your time on such answers. They only prove your lack of respect for the client and lack of professionalism. I hope that there will be less and less such restaurants in our area. And you don't embarrass yourself anymore."