Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant 105 Lincoln Way East, New Oxford, PA 17350

"Man I can't say enough wonderful things here about this pizza shop. Everytime I go in I forget to take pictures off the masterpieces on the secret menu the cook makes so that I can make everyone else jealous. So often I see couples who return weekly or more it warms my heart to know the local support a small business gets. Clearly they must do well by how many people the owners know by name! A Must Stop family owned restaurant."

"I got food poisoning here. As a matter of fact so did my wife and 5 year old. My wife was actually hospitalized from the food they serve under unsanitary conditions. She has a condition that gives her a weakened immune system so when she gets sick she really gets sick. I should have known because I saw the owner making the food which was an excuse for an Italian sub with no gloves. Didn’t think much of it but 5 hours later my whole house is sick and vomiting. Had to take my wife to the ER to get IV fluids and I missed a day of work because my kid was sick too. Lawsuit is coming."

"I ate at Pizza Garden for the first time yesterday. I bought a Large Chesse Pizza. It was delicious & very affordable. Nice friendly atmosphere in downtown New Oxford. I will be back to try one of their subs."

"A definite great place to grab a bite. Delicious food. Clean, comfort environment. Super staff. Welcomed my Service Dog (not companion...real Service Dog). Will be coming here often."

"This is not your normal pizzeria. As you walk in, you can feel the friendly atmosphere, everybody is welcoming, there are smiles on everyone's faces. It's right off the main road so it's easily accessible. It's also handicap friendly. There was Italian news on the TV and the gentlemen who helped me order and who made my food was really friendly. He made me a handful of grilled chicken for my dog and I got the super Italian sub-cold. All the way minus onions. To the owner, I'm sorry I didn't catch your name but grazie! So che la mia visita è stata breve, ma mi è piaciuta la buona compagnia."