DiCarlo's Pizza - Highlands 355 Wharton Circle, Triadelphia, WV 26059

"Very disappointing experience. We usually love DiCarlos. My husband is from Weirton and has grown up on this pizza, so we know what it is and what to expect. Unfortunately, what we got wasn't even close to our expectations. The crust was crunchy, as it should be, but not warmed at all. So when they add the cold/room temp sauce and cold cheese/pepperoni it was like eating a cold lunchable. We fully understand and appreciate the concept of adding the cheese and pepperoni after the crust/sauce are warmed in the oven, but this step appeared to be completely missed on our order. What a waste of $30! Note: We ate in the car immediately after picking it up, so it didn't cool on a ride anywhere. Very disappointing, and embarrassing because we brought our out of town guests and my husband really raved about how great dicarlos pizza is."

"Worst pizza I have ever had.. the crust was ok like a crunch French loaf, but the cheese and pepperoni were totally uncooked. The cheese was only partly melted and the pepperoni was like it was just thrown on after from the fridge."

"Ate at DiCarlo’s Pizza in Triadelphia, WV for the first time, in November 2023, while visiting nearby Cabela’s. The pizza was great! However, the location was confusing, as it is located in a plaza that requires you to go one way around a circle. Also, some of the photos posted in the Google Maps entry and reviews show an entirely different restaurant. There is no indoor eating at the Triadelphia location. Instead, it is a very small carry-out. Thankfully it was a nice day, and there are picnic tables across the parking lot. There are also NO restrooms available for patrons, and that is posted on their door. Not good for traveling customers. One of the employees appeared to be high or really out of it. I observed him smoking something outside the business’ doors after I had left. However, he did get the job done. Being a longtime fan of Ohio Valley style pizza, I was happy to be able to eat some while in the area. I definitely recommend this very unique style of pizza!"

"Good pizza, delicious red sauce, generous amount of cheese"