Pizza Man's Pizza 9 South Jefferson Street, New Castle, PA 16101

"This is our go too for pizza in New Castle. Favorite is the cheeseburger pizza. I would give 5 stars if our order would at least be consistent. But it is consistenly wrong. I order and pay online. Almost every time there is something missing. 1 time there was no toppings. Last night I ordered and paid for bacon and pickles but only got bacon. I shouldn't have to check my order before leaving. Still the pizza is delicious"

"Eh it was ok. Could be an excellent pizza but the sauce was too sweet, and I felt there was too much garlic seasoning. I’m not really a fan of garlic seasoning on pizza. Imo a good pizza should have simple ingredients. Salt, pepper and basil."

"I traveled over to Newcastle from Ohio to pick up a car part and stopped because we were hungry and found this restaurant. I must say the pizza is excellent. I came back to Ohio to get a slice of New York style pizza from Ohio a pizzeria that I go to all the time and now I hate it because I came to Pizza Man pizza and tasted their New York style pizza And it’s a huge difference. I will definitely return. I think I’m gonna drive up soon. I told my friends we were gonna do a small road trip just to get pizza they’re chicken wings are great as well. I’ve tried strawberry hot wings never had that before, but it was great , the atmosphere was nice. The people were respectful there was a little bit of a weight on the food but overall the food taste in ingredients and freshness trumps anything definitely a must stop and try. I’ll be back soon. !!!!"

"Happy with food, pricing and service. Not sure why I haven't been here before. Diamond in the rough. We'll be back."

"I love this place! One of the best pizza in new castle. My usual is the chicken, bacon, ranch pizza. I hold the ranch and have them put BBQ on it instead. It's always cool to perfection. They are also updating the restaurant which is really nice to see!"