Goodman's American Pie

"My recent visit to Goodman American Pie was a delightful experience, highlighted by their unique pizza offerings. We ordered two pizzas: the 'Rip Curl' with chicken and white sauce, and the 'Herbivore' topped with tomato, bell pepper, and various vegetables. The flavors were spot-on, with each pizza offering its own distinct and enjoyable taste profile. However, there was a slight drawback - parts of both pizzas were burned and blackened, which affected the overall enjoyment. This was a bit disappointing and the reason for my four-star rating. On a positive note, the atmosphere is very friendly, complete with a billiards table and game machines, adding a fun and relaxed vibe to the place. Great for a casual outing, but there's room for improvement in their baking consistency."

"Favorite stop when coming to ski Okemo. I have never had a bad pie here. I love the Italian sausage especially. The beer selection is good and arcade games, pool table, and lift chair seating complete the unique atmosphere."

"So I have been hunting for a really great pizza place and at last!! I found it! I moved up from Philly about a year ago and I have to say- this is some fantastic pizza. Taste, texture, and experience is an A+. Highly recommended. The staff is super friendly and I can’t wait to come back after such a warm welcome. Also, if you plan to eat there they have a secret sitting area out back that gives you a serene view of the river that cuts through the woods. Great place to relax and work on a project or take your partner on a date. Love the ambience of this place. Good vibes all around- highly recommended."