Diomede’s Restaurant

"The food was nothing short of amazing! My wife and I are fairly picky when it comes to Italian food and we were both absolutely blown away by how good everything was... and shocked that we didn't have to stand in line to get in. It was THAT good. Talk about a little known treasure! Everything was extremely fresh, the food was incredible. The atmosphere and service were excellent as well. If you're in the area and like Italian food, I highly recommend giving this place a try. We will definitely be going back and SOON."

"100% worth a stop for high quality Italian without all the city hustle. I love that this location is thriving. I remember the Fox Glove as a child (always got extra cherries in my Shirley). Diomedes did not disappoint on any level - the food was delicious, service was superb, and atmosphere was to be expected for an upper level quality restaurant. Sam our bartender was fabulous. She was very knowledgeable about the menu and gave great suggestions. I was super excited they hand stuffed Gorgonzola olives for a dirty tini. Drink specials were thoughtful and all delicious sounding. The star of the show was the food though. We only had a couple appetizers on our first visit and they were superb- tuna credo and eggplant Parmesan. Yum!"

"One of the best dining experiences we have had in years..... Great food , staff , and overall restaurant. Huge portions, excellently prepared , and serviced hot with minimal wait. Great price for such Quality! A must for anyone who likes great food. ABSOLUTELY GOING BACK AGAIN AND AGAIN ! Thanks to the staff for an awesome dining experience!"

"The place was purchased by new owners July 2023, don’t judge a book by its cover. It’s beautiful inside and the minute you walk in you get a warm welcoming feeling almost like you just came home. It’s very busy on the weekends so reservations are a must. The print out menus and put my last name on the back which was a nice little surprise. Nicky our waitress was a sweetheart and always on top of everything. From the on the house delicious bruschetta, bread with oil, tasty appetizers ( especially the meatballs) the gigantic main courses, and remarkable desserts everything was perfect. The owners Kim and Paul made themselves present, Kim greeted us like good friends when we walked in and Paul came out of the kitchen and was extremely charming. We feel like we made new friends. The prices were fair as well. I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant and definitely will return. By the way there were five in our party, I have a hearty appetite and we all had leftovers. Maybe even for two days. One more thing Paul the owner is an actor, writer, director as well. Known for Brooklyns Finest and The Sopranos."

"The only thing less than positive that I would say is that the outside of the restauraunt (in my opinion) should be updated, however once you step inside the lighting and music provide for a relaxing atmosphere. All of the staff from the host, to the waitress, all of the way to the owner himself, were extremely welcoming and friendly. I'm sure some will say it's "pricey" but you pay the same amount at olive garden, but you don't get the same experience. We got bruschetta and water automatically, bread to dip in oil and herbs, and when our food that we ordered came out it was hot, plated beautifully, and absolutely delicious. 10/10 will be back!"