Pitman Jewelry Shop 24 South Broadway, Pitman, NJ 08071

"Nice folks there. Prompt service. Reasonable prices."

"Went to Pitman Jewelry to have a custom engagement ring made. Great experience and an amazing product. Andrea and Jeff were super helpful throughout the process. Would highly recommend."

"I’ve come here a few times. Once to fix my boyfriends chain, then to buy a new chain as well. Every time I’ve come in everyone was very welcoming and kind! Its my go to jewelry shop now."

"Stopped in for batteries for 2 watches. Only took a few minutes. The staff was welcoming and very helpful in selecting a surprise ring for my wife. The way shopping local should be. Highly recommended"

"I brought my engagement ring and two wedding bands to Pitman Jewelry for resizing. I needed to get two cut off there because my fingers were swollen. Once my fingers returned to normal, I returned with the rings to get them resized. The woman who helped me looked at my rings and sized my finger and wrote everything down. I returned about a week and a half later to pick them up and was told one of the small diamonds on the band of my engagement ring fell out and that they replaced it. No one from the store had called me prior to pick-up to inform me a diamond fell out or ask if I wanted it replaced. The saleswoman who sized my finger inspected my rings closely and did not mention there was a diamond missing. I'm extremely disappointed in the lack of communication as well as frustrated that I was expected to pay for a brand-new diamond without warning. If they had informed me prior to pick up I could have made the choice to replace the diamond at a different time. I paid the total bill and left the store feeling totally taken advantage of. I didn’t want to cause confrontation while I was there, that’s not who I am, so I just paid and left because I felt I had no other choice. My marital rings are so valuable to me for so many reasons and I felt I just needed to pay and get my rings back home with me. I am writing this review to alert other potential customers about my experience in the hopes they don’t allow it to happen to them. Please use caution and be mindful when having this store work on your jewelry."