Penneys Car Care 545 Route 25A, Saint James, NY 11780

"If you live in or near St. James, Steve at Penney’s is both skilled, practical, friendly and has integrity. He will give you the pros and cons of everything so you can make the right decision for your car. My entire family has been using Steve on multiple cars for many years and we are 100% satisfied. Also, his office assistant Kathy is the best and will always try to squeeze you in if you are in a rush."

"Great service, great advice, fair prices. I highly recommend anyone to go here for any car services. They are honest and reliable. Update years later: They still have amazing service. They are the only mechanic that I trust, and refer all my friends and family to. They are often quite busy but they do find the time to fit you in and they are very clear with communication and pricing before they do any work. The reason they have so many loyal customers is because they do the right job and they are fair on pricing. If you need any work done on your car, this is the go-to place, even if it's out of your way."

"Decided to use Penny’s for all my factory maintenance instead of going to the dealer. Easy to get an appointment, honest and fair prices. Everything was completed in a couple of hours as promised! Highly recommend!"

"This is one of only two stations in Suffolk County that sell ethanol free gas. Obviously they know this so they sell it for over seven dollars per gallon. Price gouging at it's best, but hey, people are gonna pay it. Can't say much about any other aspect of this place other than it has a cool old time vibe, with the Milton Driveway bell sounding when your run over the line and friendly attendants."

"Penney’s Car Care has been trusted by my family for many years and once I got my license I started going here for car maintenance. Steve is truly an amazing mechanic, I see why my family has been going here for several years. My exhaust was super loud and my car really didn’t sound right and I needed an oil change anyway. So much work needed to be done on my car and Steve guaranteed me he would finish my car later that day since I had to explain to him I had school tomorrow. Lo and behold 5:10 I get a call to pick up my car. They are sure to give you the best deals and after driving my car for a few days, I’m absolutely blown away by how amazing my car runs and I am so happy. Steve is an absolute gem and you can for sure trust him with your car. If you want the best price and the best people who can get your car work done in not much time at all come to Penney’s. You won’t be disappointed. So much work done on my 2013 Nissan Versa. They truly fixed my car up well. I feel a lot safer on the road."