The Garden Room at Mayflower Inn & Spa

"Me and my Fiance felt like we were treated differently because of our appearance, maybe even our age. Our service was somewhat lacking, although it was not busy at all. The food was way overpriced and portions were too small to be 'shared' in the awkward menu format they are intended. I honestly recommend Lucia for anyone in the area dining on a special occasion, it is just as high end and priced similarly with better food and service. It was not all bad, the atmosphere was outstanding, and the steak was wondering, and also the young woman filling up our was extremely nice and apologetic for our service, her name does not come to mind."

"This meal exceeded even my wildest expectations. Top 10 meals I've ever had and we've travelled a ton and dine regularly in NYC. I was skeptical of the restaurant from some of the Google and Trip Advisor reviews, but those couldn't be more wrong. We got the cheese and meat dishes to start along with the trout tartare. Out of this world! Got the three cheese gnocchi as an entree. Chef Jose is a magician and our waitress Kathleen was wonderful. We'll be back again and I'm recommending this place to everyone. For other who've read the poor reviews. I was told the chef is new and they're not longer doing the prix fixe menu. From what I understand this has made all of the difference. Could not recommend a place more highly!"

"We had lunch there yesterday. We ordered two starters mussels and pea hummus. For main course. Had the steak fritz and my partner had the seafood salad. Our 4 year old had grilled cheese. We each had a glass of wine and the child had a smoothie. Honestly underwhelmed. Our meals came out before the mussels and pea hummus. My steak was ordered medium rare, it was burnt as were the mushrooms and was way over priced at $45. Partner was not impressed. Having a chef in the family, we expected more from a high end establishment. The favorite dish was the pea hummus, but the shrimp were tasteless. Our child did love the smoothie! If I had looked at the reviews before we went I’d have gone elsewhere. In my opinion, you need to have a consultant come in and retrain your staff and raise the standard."

"Stopped in for lunch on a weekday. Dining room was beautiful and food and cocktails were great. Will definitely be back next time I'm in the area"