Commack Inn 2231 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725

"ripped me off for my $20 deposits and refused to review cameras to prove that i gave it to them twice. no receipt given or anything. associate completely ignored my concern, told me i was wrong, wouldn't listen, and gave a complete attitude. very shady. oh and yes - i gave her that attitude right back after she continued to ignore me while on the phone with her co-worker. I'd like to hear from the property manager or owner. UPDATE; tried to give them another shot, they may be even worse now. health department contacted."

"New owners ..sold my home yesterday .needed 7 to 10 to move in to my new home on new years Eve with a new puppy commack motor inn staff and ownership put me on a brand new room pet friendly with more ammenities than Marriot or Hilton. Service compassion and discounted rates on new year eve.... Who does that..Commack motor inn. You've got my business for local stays Thank you thank you thank you.... I wish you and the Commack team the very best...good luck guys."

"First lets start with the positives: decenlty convenient location near the parkway and lots of places to eat/shop on Jericho Tpk. Now the negatives: Service was abysmal even for a motel. The front desk woman was rude and short with me. They require a ridiculous $300 CASH ONLY deposit just to get a room, a big ask in this day in age, especially when your stay will likely be for much less money. Next the room. Was it clean? Kinda, but I didn't take a black light to it (please someone do this). The interior was extremely dated with a mirror on the cieling above the bed. I know what this hotel is often used for... but the reminder is not appreciated. Lighting was dim and gave a gross feeling to the whole room. Finally comfort... my biggest gripe. I have stayed in many motels in my life, and I will say the pillows are usually a non-issue (especially for one night). However the pillows I slept on at the Commack Motor Inn felt like malleable ROCKS (hard to describe). You can press into them but in the morning its like a boulder was under my head, uncomfortable to say the least. I was cranky when I woke up due the pillows and had to eat and drink coffee at the nearby IHOP to cure myself. There are so many better motels (Whitman Lodge in Huntington Station, Norwich Inn in East Norwich, Chalet Inn in Centerport) with comparable and often better pricing. Save your time, money, and sleep, even if just for a one night stand, and go elsewhere."

"3 stars because the place was clean and the staff was very friendly. However, there were multiple times that housekeeping would knock once and immediately open the room door without even waiting for a response. They just walk in. This happened twice if not 3x. Thankfully, I had the chain on the door but this was a complete violation. Here's the worst part, we only had the room for 4 hours! We stopped just to get a couple hours sleep but the staff kept opening the door."

"Very descret place. Some of the rooms are a little dated but the hotel itself is perfect for what it is, a 3-hour hookup shack. For what it is it's very clean, you could tell they change the sheets after each visit. (triple sheeted beds are the way to go especially in a place like this) All being said this is definitely the cleanest Motel short-stay place I've ever been too."