Jimmy's Pizza,

822 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, United States

"47 years! It’s lovely place and admire the owner’s charisma and love for what he does. It’s about quality over quantity, the small pie is delicious."

"Questionable cleanliness. Air conditioner can't keep up. The shop is old and tired. Nice thin crust. Good sauce. Tasty pepperoni. Pizza was *****. Customers who have been coming for years may be coming for the memories."

"Jimmy was there making the pizza. He has such a thick Italian accent and he was so kind. We could see him make the pizza from scratch, it was quick to cook, and some of the BEST pizza I've EVER had!!! Would add a photo of the pizza but it was so tasty I forgot until it was already gone."

"Best pizza I've ever had. If you want some New York pizza this is the most genuine place to go. Wonderful customer service. Jimmy was extremely sweet. The pizza was so delicious and definitely a place worth going to. Highly recommend going to Jimmy's Pizza. Hopefully I will be able to go again in the future. Say hi to Jimmy."

"Jimmy's , well I had never been there drove past it and just knew it had to have good pizza. I was right. I got a Large pie, had a nice conversation with an unofficial employee and was asked to see if the pie was to my liking for the first time. Cooked in a pan and then put into the oven for a nice crisp on the bottom. Delicious out of the box and great at home out of the toaster!!"