The Proper Pizza Company

"There were several aspects of this pizza restaurant that left me feeling disappointed and considering it super overrated. Let's begin with the positive aspects. The space had a decent modern decoration, and the staff were friendly. However, even with friendly staff, one of them appeared sick and was coughing, which made me uncomfortable while placing my order. I ordered two pizzas: the Garlic Chicken pizza and the Black Truffle pizza. The first issue I noticed was with the pizza size. The size advertised on the wall was larger than what was actually served. It felt more like a kids' size pizza for the full price. Moving on to the taste, the Garlic Chicken pizza was a letdown. It had a rancid flavor, possibly due to the added sesame, which didn't taste fresh. Additionally, the garlic taste was overpowering, and the chicken had a leftover taste. On the other hand, the Black Mushroom pizza was relatively better and could be considered above average. Overall, the pizzas were overpriced considering their quality. I've had $1 New York-style pizza that was much better than what was served here. It felt unjustified to charge an extra $10 for a pizza simply because they added some nuts to it. Furthermore, the advertised prices on Google were per slice, not per pizza, which added to the confusion. I have attached a picture of the latest prices for reference. The overall experience left me feeling the prices were too high for the quality and the taste offered."

"Nice location, but I was expecting a bit more for the reviews. For 55 dollars i paid for the second largest and it really wasn't enough for 3 people. Thr crust is really thin, and although tasty when it's hot, by the time you get to the second piece it becomes chewy and hard to eat. 4 dollar extra to do half and half. Friendly staff. Bathroom down the hallway."

"This is a very unique pizza place. Usually I separate pizza into two kids: the authentic Italian and the more commercial versions with western toppings. The Proper Pizza Company manages to thread the line between the two, making some really fancy pizzas, but they also feel like they're quite innovative in their toppings. I particularly enjoyed the sesame in the crust. The shop is quite nice with a very relaxing vibe and the two workers who were there when I went were really friendly (the man even got us two fresh glasses of water when ours ran out - not something you'd expect at a pizza place). The food came out really quickly as well. I'll definitely be back to try a few of their other pizzas!"

"Great pizza and great customer service"