Stuff-A-Bagel

425 Montauk Highway, West Islip, NY 11795

● Closed

3.5 242

Hours open

Photos

Location & Phone number

About Us

Reviews

Add Review

Hours open

Monday:

5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Tuesday:

5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Wednesday:

5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Thursday:

5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Friday:

5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Saturday:

5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Sunday:

5:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Photos

Location & Phone number

Get Directions

425 Montauk Highway, West Islip, New York 11795, United States

631-661-7646

Call

About the Business

Welcome to Stuff-A-Bagel, your go-to destination for deliciously fresh bagels and baked goods in the heart of West Islip, New York. Conveniently located at 425 Montauk Highway, our cozy bakery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy a wide variety of hand-rolled bagels, expertly crafted with the finest ingredients.

At Stuff-A-Bagel, we take pride in our commitment to quality and taste. Our menu features an extensive selection of bagels, from classic plain and sesame to unique flavors that are sure to delight your taste buds. Pair your favorite bagel with our delectable spreads, or try one of our hearty sandwiches for a satisfying meal any time of the day.

Beyond bagels, our bakery also offers an assortment of freshly baked pastries, muffins, and cookies, perfect for breakfast on the go or a sweet treat to brighten your day. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or picking up a dozen bagels for the office, our friendly staff is here to ensure you have a pleasant experience.

Visit Stuff-A-Bagel today and discover why we're a beloved staple in the West Islip community. We look forward to serving you soon!

Reviews

Rene v:

"this place used to rock now it does not. Changed ownership a while ago. Now the bagels are horrible, they keep the bacon cold on the side and it’s actually so gross. Sad :("

almost 6 months ago

Koa Higgins:

"Personally I think these are the best bagels in the general Babylon-West islip area 10/10"

almost 7 months ago

Richard Ruggiero:

"Old rundown place, not friendly and food tastes like the place looked.. I got a ham sandwich on a bagel . Ham was soooo salty had to throw it out.. bagel was old and hard.. I have given this place a few tries.. that was the last one...run"

almost 7 months ago

Christina Costanzo:

"I've been here numerous times and some of the girls that work there. Just don't know how to make a sandwich or a bagel. I've never seen a bagel with so little cream cheese that I'm actually complaining about it. Usually, you complain there's too much cream cheese. I don't wanna pay ten dollars for a bagel with no cream cheese. Let's get it together n serve what we pay for. From one repeat customer who won't be coming back. Its just been happening too much I only give so many chances."

almost 8 months ago

Jerrod Pitts:

"This bagel shop is a staple of the neighborhood. When I go to Good Sam hospital, I have to stop in for a bag of bagels. They're big and delicious. The staff is also very nice and courteous."

almost 11 months ago

People also searched for

List of local businesses, places and services in New York

⭐ business help 🔍 services ☎ phones 🕒 opening times ✍️reviews 🌍 addresses, locations 📷 photos

Stuff-A-Bagel

Hours open

Photos

Location & Phone number

About the Business

Reviews

People Also Viewed

People also searched for