Blue Water Fish

"I couldn’t help but notice the disgusting 1 star review that was posted about this place this past Saturday about blue water . I have been a reoccurring customer for two years and they are the friendliest kindest staff I’ve ever been accustomed to . So let’s break down miss Eli G’s issues . 1 ) you come in on a Saturday afternoon in the beginning of August with a bunch of people and order on separate check but expect the food to all come out at the same time . Considering that I'm a chef that’s really not how that works there is a system in place for. Reason . 2) The establishment wrote a professional response to your disgusting review and you proceed to bash them because your unhappy that you didn’t get your 30 dollar refund. did you return the food or did you eat it ? 3) one thing they are good for is when they are busy they tell us the wait times. they take pride in that which I’m sure they did . Long story short if you look at the overall reviews they are a 4.8 star establishment . They work hard and will give there shirts off there back just to assure that every customer is happy . If your looking for good food and a positive vibes environment I highly recommend blue water ."

"My late grandfather owned a seafood store so I'm really picky about seafood markets. I tried this place for the first time today and they had a beautiful selection of fresh catches, as well as prepared foods, and produce. Prices were excellent, store was very clean, and the service was friendly! So glad to find this place and will definitely be back soon and often!"

"Stopped by for a quick bit for lunch. Went with the shrimp gyro and fries. The sandwich and fries were tasty but the pita fell apart making it a messy lunch. The service seemed a little slow but would go back to try some of the other options."

"My daughter and I were in the area and looking for lunch ideas, and finally settled on my suggestion to come here. She said she wasnt that hungry so I ordered her some stuffed clams. She ate half of one before saying "im sorry we didnt come here sooner" lol. Yes, the food was so good my 9 y.o. daughter actually apologized of her own free will. Im still stunned. I had the fried cod sandwich which was perfect. Everything ive tried here has been delicious. One of my fav spots on the North Fork."