Pegasus Coffee House

"Well I wouldn’t know about the coffee, I never got my order. I sat in that place for 30 minutes while the two kids behind the counter talk to their friends either on the phone or when they came in when I asked what happened to my order they said someone must of taken it. The never even called my name on my order and I was sitting at a table next to where they cash out and give out the orders. When I brought that to their attention they said they would make my order but instead proceeded to make other orders while I waited some more. I got my money back, not only for my order, but the two bags of coffee I had purchased. This place was horrible. The irony is that it is somewhat historical since this was a place where Japanese had to come to come for registration during WWII. I’m Asian American and watching white people get served before me sounds like you really get the gist of history. If you are white, enjoy this place, all others I recommend the place up the road called Cups espresso and cafe. They had one young lady talking and making orders. She was doing the job that two people at Pegasus couldn’t even do. She needs a raise. If you go tip her graciously. I was going to spend over $50 at Pegasus and you lost that business. Also when the water dispenser is empty please refill it. Although the only people getting water was me, cause I hadn’t gotten my drinks, and a black guy so that sounds about right again."

"Nestled in the serene countryside of Bainbridge Island, Pegasus Coffee is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. As the island's first coffee establishment, it exudes a quaint charm that instantly captivates visitors. Stepping into Pegasus, I was greeted by the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and the inviting scent of buttery croissants. The rustic decor and warm ambiance create a cozy retreat from the outside world, making it the perfect spot for a leisurely morning or afternoon. The coffee itself is exceptional—rich, flavorful, and expertly crafted. Whether you prefer a robust espresso or a creamy latte. And let's not forget about the croissants—they are simply divine. Light, flaky, and generously buttery, they pair perfectly with a steaming cup of coffee for the ultimate indulgence."

"One of the nicest and coolest coffee shops I’ve ever been to. We tried Vanilla Latte and Chai Tea Latte. Coffee is full of flavor. For coffee lovers, this place is heaven on earth."

"Some of the nicest people I've met in Seattle - both the staff and the locals. I found this place on maps before I even caught my flight, so today I took the ferry over to Bainbridge knowing at least Pegasus was on the other side. Originally I planned to stop by for the vegan donuts but ended up staying for 3 hours and doing some work. No one bothered me about the laptop, and on the contrary, multiple people stopped to chat to me about my camera (and accent)! Great vibes, great vegetarian breakfast bagel, great cake (and vegan donuts!), wide selection of teas, and clear knowledge of what is what regarding diets and allergens. Glad I went - wish I had time to go back!"

"We visited this adorable coffee shop twice and loved our time there. We tried a mocha, vanilla latte, pumpkin spice latte, and an americano. All delicious. Pastries were even better! Don’t sleep on the cinnamon roll! Highlight of the shop is their vibe and beautiful storefront. Perfect for that Instagram shot!"