Marty's Pizza Delafield

"Delafield WI The waitress service was fine. I ordered an extra crispy pizza. First pizza was not even close to extra crispy. The second pizza was a little more crispy but there was no crust because they CUT IT OFF, it was burning. Never had experienced this at any pizza place. They had the manager make the second pizza. Where is the cook?! Very disappointed!"

"Been coming here for nearly 20 years. Overall, a decent place. I wouldn't say it's a "must try" or that there's any "must haves" here. It's just a nice little place to go with a group of loved ones. I think they've probably achieved the atmosphere they were going for. It feels cozy enough to relax but still open and friendly without feeling too exposed or crowded. It's not anything fancy or special but it does the trick. The service is usually run by younger kids and adults who are learning their first job so they're not usually too organized or attentive. They are however well mannered and for the most part fairly competent. Again nothing special but it gets the job done without too many or large complaints. The food is rather difficult to assess as there are some things they do rather well and others they should have never tried. Generally speaking most of their food isn't anything to write home about. As pizza places go they are better than the big chains but pretty par for local hand crafted food. Their subs are basically the same as anywhere that offers them. Their buffalo wings used to draw my friends and I here for the sauce but were always disappointingly small and brittle. The chickens must have been diseased babies whose bones would all snap in half with ease. They have recently changed to larger pieces that didn't break but then they were still over cooked tough and crispy. Honestly couldn't tell you if the sauce was even still the same. There are, however, a few gems of deliciousness on their menu. Like their breads, and lasagnas."

"We ordered two 26" and two 36" pizzas for delivery with many toppings. We had several vegetarians in our outing and the pizzas were perfect. The delivery arrived at the set time for our event and the driver the friendly, professional and attentive to details. We included plates and cutlery with our order and everything was organized. The pizzas were hot, fresh and everyone enjoyed the quality. I would highly recommend Marty's to anyone hosting a large gathering in need of pizza delivery."

"A year ago we had a bad experience at this location. Poor service, undercooked pizza, and garlic bread that was 2 pieces of regular white bread toasted. We decided to not to return. Tonight, we decided to give it another chance. Thankfully, things have changed. Our server, Nathan, did a great job taking care of us. Our pizza was great. And, our garlic bread was as expected and very good, thick and tasty garlic bread. We are looking forward to our next visit."

"My lunch partner and I decided to go eat here. Because our directors name is Marty. Pizza is one of my all-time favorite foods and we loved this place we got the cheese breadsticks which were great as well as Pizza."