Haldeman's Hilltop Tavern

"Great food and service. Had the prime rib. Delicious"

"Service was great props to the bartender. Paid almost $40 for a not so good prime rib steak. Honestly I can not recommend this place to others. Lacking the brine and full flavors like I remember from the previous couple owners. The loaded baked potato was quite a joke also. 1/2 tablespoons of cheese and a half table spoon of bacon in a small cup with a lid. You dump it on. Portions size for a 1/4 potato not a full bake potato. One cube of butter and a tube of sour cream. Also came with coleslaw which wasn’t that bad. They were out of buns so wasn’t included with meal. Very bland steak and for the price, I was just not impressed. Will not be back. After this visit I no longer have the craving for the prime rib like I did in the past with the quality of the previous couple owners.I Asked for their finest cut, Owner was the cook so no excuses. I was served a poor cut of prime rib. Over cooked for medium rare, bland and chewy. Not melt in your mouth like before. Total for the prime rib meal and two drinks coast $53. I went to Marry Cody’s in onalaska same day and tried their prime rib. Wow. Night and day difference. Sorry to be so harsh I was so disappointed with the steak I had to be honest and needed redemption so went to another establishment."

"I must say the food was excellent. Not so much in regard to the poor service. I maybe could understand if it were busy. Only 3 tables of folks in there while we were there. Had to ask several times for silverware and never did get the cheese curd appetizer that we ordered. God help this place if they ever get a rush of customers!"