Fifth Avenue Bagelry

"Breakfast sandwish bagels are delicious. The bagel is soft and easy to bite into. The hazelnut coffee is always my go-to. (They dont have flavored creamers. They have half and half and milk.) They also sell lunch sandwiches. The bread is perfectly crispy. They have smoothies, boba drinks, bottled drinks, apple juice, fresh squeezed orange juice, parfaits, hard boiled eggs,, fresh pastries, and bagels with cream cheese, and their strawberry cream cheese is so tasty. It's a hot spot in the morning, so be patient. They are worth it. Don't take my word for it... Go check them out."

"Update: this is one of my regular weekend brunch spots. However today after placing my order and paid, I waited 20+ minutes and still nobody called my number. Staff passed me several times and no one asked about what I was waiting for. This is AFTER all other customers who came after me have gotten their order and the place was almost empty. When I finally asked, NOBODY had any idea about my order (#19). The person who took my order apparently left the premise. Mysteriously my order was made but put aside and nobody in the shop knew about it. They had to search and finally found the lonely bag just sitting and getting cold. Will remove this place from my regular list for a while... Paying and getting neglected is NOT enjoyable. ----- Previous review: Popular with locals and for good reason. Bagels are always fresh. Service is prompt and courteous. Wide selection of bagels but will run out of certain varieties towards late morning. Wait time can be long but they will inform you ahead of time."

"We don't have to doubt taste of all bagels. So delicious. However, their regular coffee is just normal."

"Came early around 830 AM it was very packed. I waited for the line to go down. I was looking around for the sm containers of cream cheese and couldn't find it. The arrangement was different than the last time I visited a few years ago. The register girl (very young) was not very helpful..what else...I asked her for the cream cheese flavors didn't tell me you could get bigger size in the fridge. Ordered two jalapeno cheese bagels one everything(too much onion garlic).Honey Walnut and blueberry cream cheese was amazing ($3.50 each). Turkey sandwich with pickle and the sesame bread was excellent as well."

"Nice little shop offering bagels, sandwiches, smoothies and various coffee drinks. Staff were friendly and service was quick. We were in the shop just before noon and they were out of several smoothie ingredients. This eliminated almost every smoothie on the menu. Opted for the Tropical Freeze and a blended mocha. Drinks were good. Good place for a quick breakfast or lunch or a frosty (non-alcoholic) beverage."