Mary's Pizza Shack

"Took the family out for dinner Wednesday night. 6 of us. Service was very slow. Salad were tiny for the price. Not much on them at all. Pizza was slightly burnt. Bread was cold. Chicken Parmesan was also way over cooked. I had not been in the restaurant in awhile but I won’t be back. For the price the portions were lunch size at best. $35 for a pizza that was charred. Not a fan"

"Arrived right after they opened and the hostess greeted us promptly. Our server Arianna was equally attentive and friendly. She was very knowledgeable about the menu and beers on tap. The whole experience was very enjoyable and we will definitely be back very soon."

"Great personality, responsive, and knowledgeable about everything on the menu. The ability to cater and understand our needs was exceptional! The best meatballs around, they did not short us on the toppings. Always appreciate a delicious pizza without being over charged like other pizza places."

"We love Mary’s. My daughter and I came here a couple weeks ago, and our server was so friendly and attentive that my daughter and I both commented on it how wonderful she was (young, dark hair, sad I don’t remember her name). My daughter, who also works at a restaurant, was so impressed that we left about a 30% tip. Fast forward to tonight… our hostess was very pleasant and let us know that Brooke would be our server and would be with us shortly. Brooke came to our table, no pleasantries, and asked if we were ready to order. I told her what we’d like to drink, and ordered a pizza, salad, and breadsticks. Everything was brought out on time, and tasted great. It was off putting that she just seemed like she didn’t care to help us, not that she was too busy, just that she didn’t care. When she brought the pizza, she didn’t bring or offer new plates, or ask if we needed anything, drink refills, nothing. The girls wanted ranch, so we flagged her down. One or two slices into the pizza she brought our check, again no asking if we needed anything, if we’d be ordering dessert, just a check. She never came back so we asked how she wanted us to pay. She asked if we wanted a box, we said no. Then she started offering up suggestions as to how she likes her pizza… cool, would have been a great suggestion when we were ordering. We paid, and were sitting there talking while the girls drank their sodas. She started offering them to-go sodas, we declined, and then asked if she could at least start clearing the table (with a bussing cart pulled right next to the table). Not in a friendly let me get this out of your way manner… but now it was clear this was about her watch. I just couldn’t wrap my head around how she was so unpleasant! At the end of dinner, yes, we were the only ones left In the restaurant so I get that she wanted to leave, but come on, she was rude from the beginning. I will be back, but will ask for a different waitress if I am ever seated in her section again. Kudos to the rest of the staff for doing your jobs well."

"This was my first experience here. The parking was good just avoid the rush from 5-6:30pm during the week. We did like that they have beer on draft, however our pizza was super thin crust. And didn't receive our wings until after we ate our pizza when we order wings as an app. Do not be surprised if you feel rush by the servers to leave and pay. Pizza was okay wings are better though."